Last year on another message board I saw something where there was a list of players and member voted on who they wanted removed from the list. I guess sort of a popularity contest. Anyway, I liked the idea and thought I would do that here. For starters I will post a list of 1st baseman and anyone that wants to can make one vote of who they want kicked off the list. Everyone has can vote once for each position and I will remove the top 3 vote getters.
Here is a list of the 1st baseman.

Anaheim-Scott Spiezio (Eliminated)
Baltimore-David Segui(Eliminated)
Boston-David Ortiz (Eliminated)
Chicago-Paul Konerko (Eliminated)
Detroit-Carlos Pena (Eliminated)
Kansas City-Mike Sweeney (Eliminated)
Minnesota-Doug Mientkiewicz (Eliminated)
New York-Jason Giambi (Eliminated)
Oakland-Erubiel Durazo(Eliminated)
Seattle-John Olerud
Texas-Rafael Palmeiro
Arizona-Mark Grace(Eliminated)
Atlanta-Rob Fick (Eliminated)
Chicago-Eric Karros(Eliminated)
Cinncinati-Sean Casey
Colorado-Todd Helton
Florida-Derek Lee (Eliminated)
Houston-Jeff Bagwell
LA-Fred Mc Griff (Eliminated)
Milwaukee-Richie Sexson(Eliminated)
New York-Mo Vaughn (Eliminated)
Philadelphia-Jim Thome(Eliminated)
Pittsburgh-Randall Simon (Eliminated)
Saint Louis-Tino Martinez(Eliminated)
San Diego-Ryan Klesko (Eliminated)
San Fransisco-J.T. Snow(Eliminated)

Here's the list and you have until Thursday 7:30AM Central to make you picks of who should go. I sure hope a few of you do this as it took me a while to do all this.

Please remove Erubiel Druazo.

Tim

David Segui

Here's one **NOT** to remove - Scott Spiezo. For the last 2 years, he's had a 0.998 fielding percentage.

Think about that -- almost perfect, at a position where it's vital you don't make mistakes.

And he's not a bad clutch hitter either.

eric karros

Rob Fick

So far it is a 4 way tie between Fick, Segui, Karros and Durazo.

Segui

1st round results are Segui with 2 votes and Durazo, Karros and Fick each with 1. In the event of a tie I will take the liberty of dumping the tied players until 3 have been voted off.

Voted off:Segui, Durazo and Fick

You have until Saturday morning to get your votes in for the next 3 to be knocked off.

Anaheim-Scott Spiezio -because I hate what the angels did to the Twins last year, get him out of here.

Carlos Pena.

i don't like the yankees at all i say jason giambi

Boston-David Ortiz

David Ortiz

randell simon

OMG why ortiz, he is cool can't, he needs help in the field, but he can hit if given the chance everyday to play.

Simon went 3-4 today with with 2 rbi's and 2 runs scored and is hitting .500. Iggy is not going to like this. LOL

I am somewhat curious as to why someone would vote for Carlos Pena. I think he has lots of potential and will be a great hitter one day. I thought people liked the up and coming stars.
Is it because he is with the Tigers?

Get rid of Derek Lee.

No way you throw out Simon, not now anyway!

Erubiel Durazo, he's going to be a terrible flameout.

Tim

Jason Giambi

I forgot to vote when I updated this post so I will vote off Durazo now.
The final results of round 2 are
Spiezio-1
Pena-1
Simon-1
Lee-1
Giambi-2
Ortiz-2
Durazo-2
Second round eliminations are Giambi, Ortiz and Durazo
You have until Sunday morning to get your votes in for round 3.

Since I forgot that Durazo had already been voted off I will change my vote to simon and he will go with ortiz and giambi

Carlos Pena

Tim

Pena

Derek Lee

Anaheim-Scott Spiezio

see ya scotty baby

Round 3 eliminations are
Derek Lee-1
Scott Spiezio-1
Carlos Pena-2

Mo Vaughn

Giambi

Chicago-Paul Konerko

see you paully baby you bum you should have been on the north side.

With the current lack of interest in the last couple of rounds and the fact that I am tired of this, I am going to stop doing this.
Anyone that wants to may continue.

FYI Plunge, Giambi was already eliminated.

Whoops.

damn can you at least finish the 1st basemen, I was curious who would be the last one.

Okay. I will finish 1b.
I will also vote for Meintkeiwicz.
So voted off are Meinteiwicz, Vaughn and Konerko.

Who's left?

Originally posted by Molina00
Last year on another message board I saw something where there was a list of players and member voted on who they wanted removed from the list. I guess sort of a popularity contest. Anyway, I liked the idea and thought I would do that here. For starters I will post a list of 1st baseman and anyone that wants to can make one vote of who they want kicked off the list. Everyone has can vote once for each position and I will remove the top 3 vote getters.
Here is a list of the 1st baseman.

Anaheim-Scott Spiezio (Eliminated)
Baltimore-David Segui(Eliminated)
Boston-David Ortiz (Eliminated)
Chicago-Paul Konerko (Eliminated)
Detroit-Carlos Pena (Eliminated)
Kansas City-Mike Sweeney
Minnesota-Doug Mientkiewicz (Eliminated)
New York-Jason Giambi (Eliminated)
Oakland-Erubiel Durazo(Eliminated)
Seattle-John Olerud
Texas-Rafael Palmeiro
Arizona-Mark Grace
Atlanta-Rob Fick (Eliminated)
Chicago-Eric Karros
Cinncinati-Sean Casey
Colorado-Todd Helton
Florida-Derek Lee (Eliminated)
Houston-Jeff Bagwell
LA-Fred Mc Griff
Milwaukee-Richie Sexson
New York-Mo Vaughn (Eliminated)
Philadelphia-Jim Thome
Pittsburgh-Randall Simon (Eliminated)
Saint Louis-Tino Martinez
San Diego-Ryan Klesko
San Fransisco-J.T. Snow

Here's the list and you have until Thursday 7:30AM Central to make you picks of who should go. I sure hope a few of you do this as it took me a while to do all this.

I vote this bum only because he isn't starting which i am happy about.

Chicago-Eric Karros

when is the end of this round

Ryan Klesko

Sweeney - SI's scouting report said he can't play defense.

Now eliminated, Karros, Klesko and Sweeney.
Only 2 AL'ers left. Olerud and Palmeiro

Mark Grace

Grace

Originally posted by Molina00
Last year on another message board I saw something where there was a list of players and member voted on who they wanted removed from the list. I guess sort of a popularity contest. Anyway, I liked the idea and thought I would do that here. For starters I will post a list of 1st baseman and anyone that wants to can make one vote of who they want kicked off the list. Everyone has can vote once for each position and I will remove the top 3 vote getters.
Here is a list of the 1st baseman.

Anaheim-Scott Spiezio (Eliminated)
Baltimore-David Segui(Eliminated)
Boston-David Ortiz (Eliminated)
Chicago-Paul Konerko (Eliminated)
Detroit-Carlos Pena (Eliminated)
Kansas City-Mike Sweeney (Eliminated)
Minnesota-Doug Mientkiewicz (Eliminated)
New York-Jason Giambi (Eliminated)
Oakland-Erubiel Durazo(Eliminated)
Seattle-John Olerud
Texas-Rafael Palmeiro
Arizona-Mark Grace
Atlanta-Rob Fick (Eliminated)
Chicago-Eric Karros(Eliminated)
Cinncinati-Sean Casey
Colorado-Todd Helton
Florida-Derek Lee (Eliminated)
Houston-Jeff Bagwell
LA-Fred Mc Griff
Milwaukee-Richie Sexson
New York-Mo Vaughn (Eliminated)
Philadelphia-Jim Thome
Pittsburgh-Randall Simon (Eliminated)
Saint Louis-Tino Martinez
San Diego-Ryan Klesko (Eliminated)
San Fransisco-J.T. Snow

Here's the list and you have until Thursday 7:30AM Central to make you picks of who should go. I sure hope a few of you do this as it took me a while to do all this.

Colorado-Todd Helton
I wonder what your stats would look like outside of colorado

J.T. Snow

Unlike Neifi Perez(can't really compare the two though), I think Helton would still be a very dangerous hitter outside Coors.
I also think people don't think guys like Castilla, Walker, Helton, Galarraga or Bichette can hit outside coors just because they all put up such rediculous numbers there. They may not have as good numbers but will still be up there. Perez was pretty much a Coors field hitter. Helton is not.

Jim Thome

Tim

rafeul palmaro

2-Grace
1-Helton
1-Snow
1-Palmeiro
1-Thome

I am going to go with Snow for my vote and knock off Thome to settle the tie.
By the way llcooljoe, you totally butchered Palmeiro's name.

Rafeul Palmaro? lol, anyway, will you have another contest soon? This is pretty fun.

Tim

Wow. I didn't think anyone really cared.
Well since someone actually likes this I will do second base next if 1B ever gets finished. Why are you voting for Palmeiro?
What is not to like him?

who is left?

Olerud
Palmeiro
Casey
Helton
Bagwell
McGriff
Sexson
Martinez

McGriff

Martinez

I say martinez after the fight yesterday, larussa talkinga bout the pitcher staring him down, well he never talked about tino staring the pitcher down, I would stare him down as well, but I think that fight came out of frustration, it is amazing what happens when you don't have that yankees lineup batting behind you or the fact that most teams are afraid of the yanks.

my vote martinez cause he is a scrub,

Sexton... never liked that goofy looking dude

he does look prety goofy doesn't he, I the fact that he is so tall, he just looks wierd.

Well, looks like it is McGriff, Martinez and Sexson this time.

Here is who is left now:
Olerud
Palmeiro
Casey
Helton
Bagwell

Bye-bye Palmeiro

Tim

Olerud.

Palmeiro

Olerud can take himself and his hard hat off the list.

I will vote or Casey as the 3rd guy.
So eliminated is Palmeiro(NOOOOOO), Olerud and Casey.

All that is left if Helton and Bagwell.

helton

Boot Casey, he's an over-rated bum!

I didn't think he was held with such high regard after his last couple of years. Anyway I booted Casey last round.
All that is left is Helton and Bagwell.

Oh, lol... my bad. I'm a big Helton fan so boot Bags.

Bagwell

I vote for Helton so we have a tie.
We need more people to vote.

Bagwell (I guess I'm the swing vote)

And the winner of the first base round is...........
. . .............. . ................ ...... .. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
.............. .............. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . .............. ............. . ...... . ..

In case anyone is wondering what all the dots are,
I was spelling out Helton with them.
It looked pretty good but when I posted it clumped them all together. Oh well.
helton wins anyway.

Molina, can we do this with other positions?

Just an outfielder one in general would be pretty phat to do.

Good! I wanted Helton to win. I'd love other positions. This is pretty fun.

Tim

How about 2nd base next?

Sure I can do other positions.
It will take a lot of typing doing all the good OF'ers but I will try.
Anyway, 2B will be next.

Cool!

casey,ortiz