I get:

Papplebon
Manny Rameriez


He gets:

Tom Gordon
Chuck James
Alfosono Soriano

I think it would be a good trade for you. Manny is at least equal in talent to Soriano in almost everything except for stolen bases, and I would say Pappelbon is better than Gordon. If it was me I would make the trade.

what about James. has been decent in his first couple of starts

id defintly accept that deal man

manny is heating up and hes one of the best hitters of all time

its too early to give up on him
hes an amazing hitter
and papelbon is dominant
prolly the best closer in the game rght now

it would defintly be an upgrade for your team if u accept that deal

he backed out of it now. dang it.

It depends on what type of league you are playing and what the rest of your roster looks like.As far as fantasy value is concerned, the soriano deal is worth more.Post your roster for me.

he backed out so it doesnt matter now. but my roster is on another thread in the fantasy section. you should go check it out and give me some advice.