1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Peyton Manning
3. Tom Brady
4. Drew Brees
5. Eli Manning
6. Ben Roethlisberger
7. Matt Ryan
8. Robert Griffin III
9. Josh Freeman
10. Matt Schaub
11. Andrew Luck
12. Matthew Stafford
Printable View
1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Peyton Manning
3. Tom Brady
4. Drew Brees
5. Eli Manning
6. Ben Roethlisberger
7. Matt Ryan
8. Robert Griffin III
9. Josh Freeman
10. Matt Schaub
11. Andrew Luck
12. Matthew Stafford
Most of this list is fine and reasonable, but Wilson? No way.Quote:
Originally Posted by frizzzlecake
A tear comes from my everytime he throws a longball, his WR's are well below average, half way though the season and he lead the Hawks to 6-4 while last year they went a total 7-9. He beat Brady/Cam/Rodgers*, and is really coming into his own the last couple of games. He's got 1800 passing on the season with 15 Touchdowns I know it doesn't sound a lot but he has one of the lowest Passing attempts in the league 29th if he got more attempts no doubt in my mind would he be in many peoples lists.imoQuote:
Originally Posted by mugatu471
i have to agree with gladdy on Eli, and i'm a giants fan. Very average yr so far.
What does he have 12 td's, 11 int's? had such a great start
Brady
rodgers
brees
peyton
griffin
freeman
schaub
Big Ben
Luck
A Smith
1. Rodgers
2. Peyton
3. Brees
4. Brady
5. BigBen
6. Eli
7. Matt Ryan
8. Josh Freeman
9. Dalton
10. Rivers
How does anyone justify putting RG3 on a top 10 list and leaving Josh Freeman off?
Josh Freeman is really eh. I would have ZERO faith in him in a game, but not nearly as much lack of confidence as I would have in Rivers, who has fallen off harder than any other QB.Quote:
Originally Posted by duane1969
I don't know how anyone could leave RG3 off a top 10 list, especially with the weak QB play overall these days. The guy is a star.Quote:
Originally Posted by duane1969
I understand that people have different opinions on lists like these..... but ultimately a players career needs to be taken into consideration when making the list. Although Eli hasnt played that well this year he plays big in big games and always has. He will throw up some stinkers but his best is on the level with brady, peyton, rodgers....... and rookies are difficult to guage. Its tough for me to list an RG3 on a losing team as a really high rated QB...at the same time its also hard to rate Luck really high because he has as many td's as interceptions...... anyway, here is my list.
1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Tom Brady
3. Peyton Manning
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Drew Brees
6. Eli Manning
7. Matt Ryan
8. Matt Schaub
9. Ribert Griffin
10. Andy Dalton
im surprised to see schaub on most of these lists. i personally think he's been bottom top ten for a few years dispite his numbers of late. anyway here's mine :)
1. rodgers (yeah he tore up houston so i give credit where its due)
2. brady
3. peyton manning
4. brees
5. roethlisberger
6. eli manning (seems to be contriversial, but romo is just as talented yet loses in any real game while eli wins them. the fact is he wins when it counts)
7. matt schaub
8. matt ryan (not completely sold on ryan yet, but i'll give him his dues for now)
9. andrew luck (7-1 in games decided by one score. multiple come back last second wins. this guy is the real deal dispite some of his stats)
10. RG3 (could be several qb's at this spot, so i just picked one)
1001. mark sanchez (another matt leinart. i never liked this guy. same as flacco. both have been over rated since they came in the league. although i wouldnt put flacco last)
1 vick
2 sanchez
3 tebow