RGIII or Luck?
Printable View
RGIII or Luck?
Unfortunately, I think a lot of it will be based off how well each performs in the post-season. If you go by pure stats alone and how much each one meant to their team, I think it belongs to RGIII.
Votes have to be turned in before the playoff games start I believe...Quote:
Originally Posted by rchurchward
---
It should clearly be RG3 if we're looking at the stats followed by Russell Wilson, but it'll probably be Andrew Luck because the media hype (even though his stats are extremely underwhelming in comparison)
Chandler Harnish gets my vote.
RGIII outplayed Luck in college last year and won the Heisman, so even though he had better stats than Luck in their rookie season, the NFL will want Luck to win something.
Blair Wal$h!
Its Robert Griffin III...no doubt about it.
RGIII - 3,200 yards 20 TD 5 INT - 815 rushing 7 TD's, 12 fumbles
Russell Wilson - 3,118 yards 26 TD 10 INT - 489 rushing 4 TD's, 5 fumbles
Luck - 4,374 yards 23 TD 18 INT - 255 rushing 5 TD's, 10 fumbles
That is the order i'd put them in for the ROY with maybe Doug Martin finishing a close 4th. It will be close between RGIII and Wilson.
not a bad class, i'd have to go with griff
I agree with you 100% on that one, Luck is a great game winner but not a good statistical QB like Wilson & RG3. I think RG3 deserves it, but as has been mentioned already, it depends if Luck can topple Baltimore and RG3 can beat the Hawks.Quote:
Originally Posted by gladdyontherise