feeling a little screwed over by panini.............what do you guys think

[MR.M's Cards]

after waiting 14 months on a redemption and with several unanswered emails I finally was told by panini today that they dont have my card and would be sending a replacement of equal or greater value. What do you think of the replacement. I was suppose to receive this :
2010 Panini Dominion
Signatures Ruby /50

Instead I am getting this:

2011 Panini Crown Royale
All the Kings Men Memorabilia Signature /100

my first reaction is im not overly impressed with the replacement, i think mainly because I waited all this time to get a card I already own. what do you think?

[HockeyCardMan]

that was not a good replacement. Sorry to hear

[shawner]

Sorry man!

[PensFan7187]

I've found that my replacements have really sucked compared to the original cards I was expecting. They do not take into account any preference.

[centrehice]

What were the players? You didn't say what player belonged to the #/50 Ruby Auto, and what player belonged to the #/100 Auto.

That....I'm afraid is the $64,000.00 question.

[g-force]

I think this depends on the players as well, although and auto memorabilia card /100 sounds as good or better than an auto /50. Just my opinion though.

[andrewconnors9]

Dominion /50 is a nice hard sign though, crown royale is a sticker. Bad replacement if its the same player

[Mnum]

They did the same to me. But yours is way worse. How can you replace a Dominion Product with Crown Royale, What did they send you? What was the original cards supposed to be?

[MR.M's Cards]

sorry both cards were of bobby ryan......I have the crown royal, not bad card but nothing special, i would trade in for an auto dominion /50 in a heart beat.

[comfortably9numb]

maybe explain your displeasure with the process? I've heard of people calling and if you get a person in a good mood they will correct it...check the BV's of the cards for evidence and just be nice...sugar gets you farther than vinegar...but yeah, that's a terrible replacement