03-27-2013, 04:26 AM #1
Can someone make a LEGAL argument against gay marriage?
I'm getting sick of the right wing side of this debate... all they do is speak about religion, morals, how children need a mom and dad.. etc etc etc... none of them have made a single legal argument in favor of their side of the debate.
A law that restricts a right, rather than clarifying a right is always a bad law. Prohibition, drug laws, interstate tariffs, none of these things have ever been popular, and most have been struck down... just as DOMA will be this week.
Legally.. we cannot legislate morality, not your morals, not my morals, no one's morals.... equal protection under law means homosexuals have the right to be married, period.
Morally... is it any of your business, my business, or anyone else's business what 2 consenting adults do with their lives? I love how right wingers scream "government needs to stay out of my life".... then want the government to regulate the rights of marriage, abortion, drug use, and whether or not we pray in public. Nothing hypocritical here.
so lets hear it right wing, DOMA supporters... or anyone generally against gay marriage. Lets hear a LEGAL argument about it. Stop trying to legislate your morals!
Last edited by Imac7065; 03-27-2013 at 04:52 AM.For an updated look at what I have for sale or trade please click my eBay User ID.... usually thousands of items available in all genre's
03-27-2013, 04:47 AM #2
We did this a while back....guess how many GOOD arguments we got?
And that's because they KNOW it to be true....there are no good reasons.
Any person that is anti-gay marriage is ether a bigot or in some way ignorant of reality."The word god is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weakness..."
03-27-2013, 08:44 AM #3
I think the only real legal defense is that this redefines marriage from being understood as between a man and woman to something else. (man/man, etc)
Also - since it is state who recognizes marriage in general I could see them making it states rights issue and kicking back to individual states to decide.
Last edited by matt_curren; 03-27-2013 at 08:47 AM.Needs: Brewers Pitcher Mark Rogers '04 pick
Red Sox - HOF & Current Players
Current Patriots Cards
Larry Bird, Carmelo/Lebron/Wade RC's
03-27-2013, 09:44 AM #4
equal protection under law means homosexuals have the right to be married, period.
the only issue I have is how the government, including the military and business' will find the money to pay for all the new benefits?
not a legal issue, just a thoughtJay Shrewsbury
03-27-2013, 10:19 AM #5
Besides religion there is no reason not to have gay marriage in the United States. It is impossible to have an argument against gay marriage without religion. BTW I do believe in God and the bible but not everyone else does so it is not my call nor it is the call of the gov't to push christanity or any other religion for the matter on non believers. What two consenting adults do in the privacy and comfort of their own bedrooms or who that want to marry for that matter is of no intrest to me. I have my own life and marriage to worry about.
03-27-2013, 11:00 AM #6
B)... you're really going to justify prejudice by asking how much it might cost in tax revenue? Holy hell dude. "We cannot free the slaves because it will cripple the south's economy"... sound familiar?For an updated look at what I have for sale or trade please click my eBay User ID.... usually thousands of items available in all genre's
03-27-2013, 11:22 AM #7
The idea that if a legal argument can not be made then there is no valid argument is asinine. No legal argument can be made against sex with animals. No legal argument can be made against driving 200MPH. No legal argument can be made against citizens owning nuclear weapons. These are all social issues and people have a right to their own opinion about social issues.
03-27-2013, 11:25 AM #8
03-27-2013, 11:27 AM #9
03-27-2013, 11:28 AM #10