Black or ultimate?

[mugmasher]

Good morning everyone so I want to get one more case of hockey and the two that are coming out that I would like are upper deck black and ultimate collection. But I can only get one or I get thrown out of my house LOL. So I was wondering which one would have the better value the four box case of black? Or the five box case of ultimate the black is $200 less than the ultimate but if I'm going to get one I figured I would get the one with the best bang for the buck. I know this sounds like a stupid question but I always like the ideas of the collectors

[theboxbreaker96]

Ultimate has gone down hill. Black is new but I'm guessing the cards will be stunning. Also I think a much better chance for bigger hits. I would go with black 100% of the time.

[dudical]

Neither, SP Authentic :)

[RGM81]

Why not Premier?

Of the two, go with Black. Ultimate is going to be shared on e-Pack this year which means that inevitably certain key hits will not be available through the physical format.

[mugmasher]

RGM81 I am still getting the premier actually it's on it's way ( me birthday gift to me this Sunday �� ..but I have both the ultimate and black on reserve and I can only buy one of the two when they come out so I was wondering the best value .

[rydlar99]

Black. Ultimate value will be watered down after it gets flooded on comc.

[creasecollector]

I'd go with some UD Black. Best of luck ! !

[thorni2]

I'd go with Ultimate, it has better rookies.

[jim bradt]

Go with Black. Ultimate in my opinion is so so.

[MattDMC]

Neither, SP Authentic :)

^ This.

But since its not an option and the choices are Black or Ultimate I'm taking a shot on Black. Beautiful cards and it will be a fresh release that hasn't been out for a while while Ultimate has been getting worse and worse over the years.