First name:    Last name:    Sport:    

Phil Simms Addresses Report   Sport: Football

Player overall success: 67%

   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 67%    
Total number of submission on this address: 154
# of Success: 68  # of Failed: 34  # of Pending: 52
Added by:michelrivolta   Added on: 06-29-2009
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
RedskinRussell 08-03-2020 Pending -2/0Sent 87 Topps and 88 Topps 
BrandonPyc 07-28-2020 Pending -3/0  
dish142002 07-28-2020 Pending -2/0  
whitemamba 07-22-2020 Pending -1/0sending a past and present performers Topps card already signed by Eli with handwritten note and top loader 
TripleTTyler50 07-21-2020 Pending -1/0  
Joeroc28 07-13-202007-25-2020Success 122/2Great signature 
Jabroni-Mets-Fan 07-13-202007-24-2020Success 112/21988 Topps, 1990 Pro Set 
crbaughn62 07-06-2020 Pending -3/0N 
kurtkurtkurtalan 07-01-2020 Pending -1/01 card sent 
Leeburtt 06-23-202007-11-2020Success 182/2  
Piester 06-13-202007-06-2020Success 231/1  
dct0824 06-12-202007-07-2020Success 252/2  
jfallon 06-09-202007-25-2020Success 462/2Sent 2 cards//signed both!
warlordforever04 06-02-202006-08-2020Success 62/3SENT 2 CARDS AND GOT 3 PICS BACK SIGNED NOT MINE THAT COOL 
TheCajunCollected 06-01-2020 Pending -3/0  
Wolverine 05-21-2020 Pending -2/0Sent LOR, SASE and 2 cards. 
alabamagator925 05-15-2020 Pending -2/0  
Bisons87 05-15-2020 Pending -1/0  
jdresbach 05-15-2020 Pending -1/0  
IAK683 05-15-202007-24-2020Success 702/21984T, 1991F- both signed Thanks Mr. Simms 
Sjuschmitty 05-06-202006-10-2020Success 351/1  
thorgy213 04-23-202005-13-2020Success 203/3SASE-NOTE-3 cards / HUGE SUCCESS, was hoping for one got all 3 back signed nicely..
Piester 04-12-2020 Pending -2/0  
Oriolesrise 04-11-2020 Pending -1/082 Topps 
kellykruse23 04-11-2020 Pending -1/01 card 
TheCajunCollected 03-13-202005-15-2020Success 631/11 card signed :D 
JeffFMcCormack 03-10-2020 Pending -1/0I sent a 1991 Fleer card. 
NickBosa97 02-27-202003-20-2020Success 211/1Signed Card. 
quickstraw 01-31-202006-10-2020Success 1301/1Sent 8 x 10 ... Signed it. 
Leeburtt 01-13-202001-18-2020Success 51/1  
pbtank67 01-06-2020 Pending -1/090F. 
mnbigfoot 01-02-2020 Pending -5/0(2) 1988 Topps, 1990 Pro Set, and (2) 1991 Fleer. Pending. 
spikeowen 12-31-201901-21-2020Success 214/486t, 90ap, 92 Gameday, & 18 Elite Title Waves - signed all 4 beautifully in blue.
kandiclipper 12-27-2019 Pending -1/0  
alabamagator925 12-23-2019 Failure -2/0came back unsigned again 
Snapper06 11-27-201912-21-2019Success 242/2  
RIFF RAFF 77 10-25-201912-21-2019Success 571/1  
bigd8690 10-22-201901-03-2020Success 731/1Sent an 8x10. Received signed in black sharpie with Super Bowl MVP inscription 
spwhitta 10-09-201902-03-2020Failure 1172/0RETURNED UNSIGNED IN RETURN ENVELOPE. 
LoneRanger1975 10-01-201910-22-2019Failure 214/0Sent four cards and a hand written letter. I sent a pic of us together and explained I was a childhood fan of his. Received back all four cards unsigned ????????????. 
jaymz887 09-13-201902-05-2020Failure 1451/1mailed out 1 card and $5 got it back yesterday card was not signed and he kept the $5 
aeich11 08-31-201910-22-2019Failure 521/1Returned my 1 card + letter in my SASE - as big of a prick as he appears on TV i guess. 
Craiggb 08-20-201902-03-2020Failure 1671/0Returned unsigned 
twinsfan83 08-14-201910-07-2019Success 542/21990 Score 
Sjw3315 08-05-201908-13-2019Success 82/2Two cards inscribed #11 and super bowl xxi mvp 
Leeburtt 07-16-201901-21-2020Failure 1892/0giving up 
Danmay55 07-15-2019 Pending -2/0  
Robcleveland3 07-03-201907-11-2019Success 81/0Sent $10 along with two cards, one for him to keep. He returned the $10 and signed both! LOVE the way these cards autograph.
StarrsCards 03-27-201904-12-2019Failure 162/0Sent both card back unsigned and sealed the letter with something so sticky it stuck to the letter I wrote. Took a solid 3 minutes to open the envelope. 
evoniukus 02-16-2019 Pending -1/0Sent 2 89 Score, LOR and SASE. 
pmc14 02-01-201903-13-2019Failure 391/0Returned card unsigned. Used my SASE. 
EnSeguida 01-19-201903-11-2019Failure 502/2Returned my cards unsigned 
chicagobullsjoe 01-11-2019 Pending -1/0Sent 1 Card and SASE 
tc123 12-21-201803-01-2019Failure 701/1Sent Card 
Craiggb 12-21-2018 Pending -2/0Cj 
Craiggb 12-08-2018 Pending -4/0  
tilt122 12-08-201812-20-2018Success 121/1Signed in black sharpie. I am in heaven! 
Craiggb 11-13-201811-26-2018Success 133/3  
nflfootballnut 07-23-2018 Pending -1/01988 TOPPS 
Tbird21 06-08-2018 Pending -2/0sase 
RacinDan 06-02-2018 Pending -3/0Sent LOR, 3 TC, SASE 
reachrulz 04-30-2018 Pending -1/0  
Spikes40 03-21-2018 Pending -3/0  
34BoJackson16 03-20-2018 Pending -1/0(1) 2011 Panini card 
Danmay55 02-28-201803-19-2018Success 181/1signed 1 card i sent 
cutchamin 02-13-201803-16-2018Success 302/22 Pro Set cards 
LoneRanger1975 01-25-201803-14-2018Success 475/4Mailed five cards with a heart felt note. He signed four in a black Sharpie but not the fifth. Still stoked and thrilled with the return. 
HouseOfCards 12-28-201702-06-2018Success 401/11 Score in black Sharpie 
Yanksfan876 10-25-2017 Failure -1/0write off 
rpcowin 08-05-201708-14-2017Failure 91/0sent my card back unsigned using my SAE 
delones24 05-18-201708-17-2017Success 913/394 Score, 89 Topps, 91 UD
Spikes40 04-22-201705-11-2017Failure 193/0RTS All 3 returned unsigned in my postage paid envelope 
Sten5123 04-01-201704-17-2017Success 162/2Very suprised about this one, cards look great. I sent 2 cards and signed both in nice black sharpie! Thank you Mr. Simms 
marty77 12-16-2016 Pending -3/0  
alabamagator925 11-04-2016 Failure -2/0I'm moving and it never came back 
Toupal 09-08-201609-19-2016Failure 110/0Sent card and letter back unsigned 
broncosfan13 07-01-201607-15-2016Failure 142/0sent cards back unsigned 
bigscoop13 05-01-201606-20-2016Failure 502/0I don't know what is up with Mr. Simms. I have sent to him 3 different times. Twice I got return to sender and the most recent, my cards were sent back not signed in my return envelope. I don't know why some people are getting returns and some aren't 
dvsantan 02-05-201602-10-2016Failure 51/0My envelope was opened and card was returned in SASE but no auto... may have been away for Super Bowl? 
bickel84 02-02-201602-11-2016Failure 91/0Sent 1987 Topps...returned card unsigned. 
Pauls1976 12-26-201501-09-2016Success 141/1Sent LOR, SASE & 1 90 Pro Set. Received back in black sharpie! Very cool, thank you Mr Simms! 
AthletesAutograph 12-17-201501-11-2016Success 252/2Great sig on both my cards pretty fast return 
AthletesAutograph 12-17-201501-11-2016Success 252/2Great sig on both my cards pretty fast return 
bigscoop13 10-19-201511-12-2015Failure 242/0I sent one envelope with two cards, never got them back so I tried again and got a Refused, RTS yellow sticker Unable to forward. Not sure what is going on. 
Pedroia15TheBest 08-24-2015 Pending -2/0  
Yanksfan876 08-24-201510-23-2017Failure 7912/0write off 
EKritzell 08-20-201501-01-1910Failure -385822/0Sent 88 and 89 Topps. It's been a year, I'm gonna write this one off 
Philly4Life 08-20-201509-30-2015Success 411/1Sent Giants mini helmet, LOR, SASE and $10. Asked for as inscription. Looks awesome with SB MVP inscription as asked! 
Ebys23 08-17-2015 Pending -1/090 Pro Set 
babco-luca 08-14-201505-07-2016Pending 2671/0  
marty77 08-14-2015 Pending -3/01986 and 1988 Topps, 1991 Pro Set 
spikeowen 08-13-2015 Pending -3/080t, 86t, 89ps 
BSRice 08-03-201508-10-2015Success 71/1 
dareyl 08-01-201508-12-2015Success 112/2 
cbtvideos 07-02-2015 Pending -1/0Sent one 1992 SkyBox Prime Time trading card, letter, and SASE. 
ellwoodbandrules 06-08-201507-06-2015Success 283/33 Cards Signed in Black 
chr5399 03-24-201507-06-2015Success 1041/6Signed nicely in black Sharpie... sent 6, asked to sign 1, nice guy, signed and sent back all 6... 1990 Pro Set SB21 MVP, '90 Score Hot Gun, '91 Topps, '91 Upper Deck, 2000 Upper Deck NFL Legends, 2012 Topps RC Reprint... My all-time favorite NFL player. 
mrREALiTi 03-03-2015 Pending -2/0  
Saint On Sundays 10-20-201405-26-2015Success 2183/3Three cards in blue sharpie. 
spikeowen 08-25-2014 Pending -4/03 87' Topps cards and a Super Bowl MVP card 
Soeren2811 08-14-201402-02-2016Failure 5373/0sent 1 TC, 2 pictures; TTM to Germany 
Estesjl 07-07-2014 Pending -1/0  
Coltron57 06-30-2014 Pending -3/03 cards 
handifan2010 01-18-2014 Pending -2/0  
pwmullen3 09-30-2013 Failure -1/0been over a year... don't think it's coming back 
lizard-jd 09-03-201305-27-2014Success 2662/1After 4 tries sending with my Spanish name without a success, sent this one in my wife's American name & he signed the CIC. Don't think he likes Spanish people... 
Ryanmillerfan30 08-12-201305-27-2014Success 2883/3  
silojohnson 08-03-201308-13-2014Success 3752/2'12 Topps QB immortals and '12 Topps RC Reprint very awesome success thanks Mr. Simms! Dated May 24th... the USPS isnt very good at forwardin i guess :/ 
jimmyf21 08-01-201305-27-2014Success 2991/1mailed 1 card - received card back autographed 
jmintz 07-29-201305-31-2014Success 3061/1Nearly a year later, and the card arrives with a super-clean auto! Stoked for this!
Tibbs11 07-15-2013 Pending -1/0  
jaymz887 06-15-201307-10-2013Success 254/4great signer got all 4 cards signed 
dickieiii 04-19-201307-11-2013Success 831/1Glad to get this one back :) Probably gonna send another. 
bballcrazy10 03-23-2013 Pending -2/01994 Fleer and IC 
GoWarrior 03-07-201304-04-2013Success 271/1Trying again. Sent an 8x10. WOW signed and inscribed with #11 and SB XXI MVP. Looks amazing! 
DJSkopes 01-17-2013 Pending -3/0  
rcgdodge 06-15-201207-10-2013Success 3901/1Awesome success, took over a year but who cares!! 
delones24 05-21-201209-06-2013Failure 4731/0Write Off 
Csarge8 05-10-2012 Pending -2/0  
RedSox0518 04-18-201207-22-2013Success 4601/1Was going to write this off, but was returned in the mail signed today. Beyond thrilled with this return and signature, thanks a ton Mr. Simms!! 
Lapo0013 03-31-2012 Pending -2/0Sent mcfarlane base and 1 jersey card 
dtwohig 03-22-201206-18-2012Success 881/1Signed card 
Jeremy_Falcons 12-19-201103-19-2012Success 901/1Awesome success from the HOFer himself
Texas Red 12-05-201106-18-2012Success 1952/2Got it back today. I might have sent it even before December. I'm just guessing. Thank You Mr. Simms! 
GoWarrior 11-23-201111-30-2011Failure 73/0Sent three 8x10s and asked to personalize for me, my brother, and sister. Writing it off as a failure. 
wolfman4christ 10-13-2011 Pending -1/0  
ydfthunder 08-26-2011 Failure -2/0RTS 
bball15fan 08-19-201110-13-2011Success 551/1Mini Helmet 
vikesfan40 08-01-2011 Pending -1/0  
DETFAN1 07-22-201108-26-2011Failure 351/0RTS/Refused! Might try again. 
lizard-jd 07-10-201108-22-2011Failure 432/0LOL!!! RTS but at least he's sending my stuff back these days - he hates me! 
arfmax 06-25-201107-05-2011Success 102/290 Score/2011 Panini National Treasure Ring of Honor #81/99 
Csarge8 06-06-201107-02-2011Success 264/4Thanks Phil.. Great signer 
crazylax30 06-06-201107-05-2011Success 291/1Thanks mr simms 
gladdyontherise 06-03-201102-09-2012Failure 2511/0RTS 
bball15fan 05-26-201107-02-2011Success 371/1SI 8x10 
blkdodge 03-21-201105-31-2011Success 711/1Signed 8x10 
tampacannon 03-16-201104-04-2012Success 3851/1Finally came back and it looks beautiful with both autos!! Thanks to both!!!
coltsfan 02-28-201107-05-2011Success 1261/1sent 94 skybox card... Phil signed in blue sharpie. 
bronxbomber 02-26-201102-09-2012Failure 3482/0RTS Unable to forward. Almost a year later. 
REDANDGOLDPRIDE 02-20-201102-14-2012Failure 3591/0RTS Unable to forward after nearly a year. Weird.. 
Gridiron63 12-15-201001-31-2011Success 472/2Signed both in Black Sharpie! Thank You Mr. Simms! 
theRaineman 06-25-201001-31-2011Success 2201/1veru surprised with this return, signed my super bowl commemorative card....nice success! 
skinsfan0521 05-24-2010 Pending -1/0Sent LOR, SASE & 5x7 
wmhc28413 04-09-201006-19-2010Success 713/3 
xtra-innings 02-27-201006-21-2010Success 1134/4 
indyreds 10-28-2009 Pending -1/0  
Miss Inertia 09-07-200909-18-2009Success 111/1Great signer! Fast turnaround!
nycsportsnews 08-13-2009 Pending -1/0  
ar1888 06-05-200906-12-2009Success 71/1Giants mini helmet 
michelrivolta 01-30-200906-29-2009Success 1491/1 
lizard-jd 11-02-200807-09-2011Failure 9792/02 Topps not coming back! 
RockiesFan33 03-28-200806-21-2010Success 8151/1Signed my 8x10! Dates are correct! 815 days!
RockiesFan33 04-04-200706-21-2010Success 11741/1Signed my card. Dates are correct! 1174 days!


About SCF

Sports Card Forum provides sports and non-sports card collectors a safe place to discuss, buy, sell and trade.

SCF maintains tools that will allow collectors to manage their collections online, information about what is happening with the hobby, as well as providing robust data to send out for Autographs through the mail.

Follow SCF on