Here is where I am with my set:

15 Edgar Martinez (incoming)
24 Orlando Cabrera
34 Mike Mussina (pending)
53 Sean Casey (incoming)
58 Dontrelle Willis (pending)
130 Miguel Batista
146 Larry Walker (incoming)
202 Chad Gaudin AR
210 Khalil Greene AR
212 Prentice Redman AR
214 Clint Barmes AR
215 Matt Kata AR (pending)
216 Jon Leicester AR
217 Jeremy Guthrie AR

Still need the rest!