UD Replacement Card - Do you think its a fair replacement?

[luckyrollers]

I busted two boxes of 2007 sweet spot and got a redemption card of Tim Linecum.

TIM LINECUM
2007 SWEET SPOT BASEBALL SWEET SPOT SIGNATURES TIER 2 GLOVE LEATHER SILVER INK SS-TL

But the issue was that they ran out of that card and sent me a replacement card:
2007 UD Black Game day Ticket Auto of Tim Lincecum 3/10



Do you think this is a fair trade? What is the bv of this card?

[ElectricFriar]

Personally, I'd rather have the Sweet Spots card. To me, this one, while numbered 3/10, doesn't have the look or wow factor that Sweet Spots does.

And since this is only numbered to 10, I doubt that Beckett would place any pricing on it, due to "scarcity".

[themanishere]

Nice card!

I'd say that is an awesome replacement, all things considered. While it may not look as nice as a Sweet Spot, I think the value is relatively similar.

[JKC]

Very nice card! Congrats!

Thanks for sharing!

Darin

[gladdyontherise]

I'd say thats a better replacement!

[johan29lhp]

i'd say its pretty equal yeh. the black leather silver ink sweet spots are awesome, but this is a great replacement. at least they didnt send you a bunch of no-names!

[piggy1918]

As johan said, at least you still got a Lincy auto. But I'd take the SS auto, they seem to sell MUCH better than the UD Black (especially those line-up cards). Overall not too bad.

[xpress34]

And another STRIKE against Redemption Cards... How can you 'run out' of a card that is a Redemption??? Did you make more Redemption Certificates than you did cards?

Personally, I'd rather have the SS as well.

- Chris

[Stl_Cardinals_Fan]

Pretty fair replacement. It's /10, so there won't be a BV most likely, but it's of a great player (the same player you redeemed initially too) so I'd be happy with it if I was a fan of him.

And another STRIKE against Redemption Cards... How can you 'run out' of a card that is a Redemption??? Did you make more Redemption Certificates than you did cards?

That's a valid point.

[andrewcstein]

I'd complain for sure.

Of course, I'd probably complain if they gave me a better card than the one I requested, but that's just on principle.