Upper Deck Replacement, not to sure........

[13stepper]

I can't decide if I received a good damage replacement from Upper Deck or not. This is the card I sent in:

$18 tracked shipping incured


This is what I received in return:






Thoughts and opinions please.

[markshew]

the book value on the auto jersey is more than the patch

[piper1]

If you were a collector of Lecavalier the replacements would be a disappointment as that original card was a definite keeper. If you are more about the dollar value you are well ahead on the new cards.

[Estovia]

If you were a collector of Lecavalier the replacements would be a disappointment as that original card was a definite keeper. If you are more about the dollar value you are well ahead on the new cards.

+1

Unless you were particularly attached to that specific LeCavalier dual patch, I would take those replacements and run.

[RGM81]

Lecavalier patch cards are pretty much dime a dozen these days - while those ones were pretty decent to look at, I tend to view an autographed memorabilia card as an upgrade. Plus you got a pretty nice auto of an up-and-coming young star.

[Gallinator]

Slightly better replacement than original, IMO. Shame about the $18 shipping it in, though - is that the only way they will accept a card? (I'm getting ready to file for a damage replacement, too)

[ilooklikeandy]

Slightly better replacement than original, IMO. Shame about the $18 shipping it in, though - is that the only way they will accept a card? (I'm getting ready to file for a damage replacement, too)

It should be a lot cheaper for shipping within the US.

[thorni2]

What was wrong with the original card?