Are these Mickey Mantles Cards Original?

[McMahonFan]

The border on the 58 one is too white- Topps borders from that set were slightly brown hued because of the quality of paper they used. That one for sure isnt real- I wouldnt touch ungraded mantles in that condition with a 50 foot pole unless they were PSA graded and the seller was reliable- stay clear

Spot on!! Stay clear of cards like this, unless they're graded or from someone you know. Whoever is selling these to you, knows what they are, they're playing dumb in hopes they land a sucker..

[miller1032]

Thank you for all the feedback everyone! It's much appreciated!

[rtsjr]

if its too good to be true then it is

[mckinneyj]

50-50 centering on cards from this era is relatively rare - and those overly white borders (as has already been pointed out) are also an indicator of their lack of authenticity.