View Poll Results: Better all time 25 man roster

Voters
7. This poll is closed
  • Orioles

    2 28.57%
  • Phillies

    5 71.43%
Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Orioles vs Phillies

  
  1. #1




    Join Date
    Mar 2018
    Posts
    484
    SCF Rewards
    1,071
    Country
    Anaheim Angels Alabama Crimson Tide Chicago Bears

    Orioles vs Phillies

    Who has a better all time 25 man roster? Who would win if these two teams faced off?

    Orioles

    C: Chris Hoiles, Rick Dempsey
    1B: Eddie Murray, George Sisler
    2B: Bobby Grich, Brian Roberts
    3B: Brooks Robinson, Harland Clift
    SS: Cal Ripken Jr, Bobby Wallace
    LF: Ken Williams
    CF: Paul Blair, Brady Anderson, Adam Jones
    RF: Frank Robinson
    SP: Jim Palmer, Mike Mussina, Urban Shocker, Jack Powell, Dave McNally
    RP: Hoyt Wilhelm, Stu Miller, Dick Hall, Gregg Olson, Darren O'Day

    Phillies

    C: Jack Clements, Darren Daulton
    1B: Fred Luderus, John Kruk
    This Ad will be removed when you a member of sportscardforum.com


    2B: Chase Utley, Nap Lajoie
    3B: Mike Schmidt, Dick Allen
    SS: Jimmy Rollins, Larry Bowa
    LF: Ed Delahanty, Sherry Magee, Billy Hamilton
    CF: Richie Ashburn
    RF: Bobby Abreu
    SP: Robin Roberts, Steve Carlton, Pete Alexander, Cole Hamels, Curt Schilling
    RP: Turk Farrell, Ron Reed, Jim Konstanty, Ryan Madson, Tug McGraw

  2. #2




    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Posts
    16,654
    SCF Rewards
    2,923
    Country
    Baltimore Orioles Washington Nationals

    I'll go with the "O's"/"Birds". However, at SS I'd replace Wallace with Aparicio, and pitchers Shocker and Powell with any two of these - Milt Pappas, Steve Barber,Mike Cuellar, and catcher Chris Hoiles with Gus Triandos.

  3. #3







    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Posts
    46,023
    SCF Rewards
    7,300
    Country

    Phillies by a little bit on this one. The O's pitching is just weaker and I think they might have a worse offense (though that one is much closer IMO). Also I would still like to see Ryan Howard on the Phillies roster. Even if he was atrocious defensively at 1st he should be on there for his offense alone. The guy was a legit dominant force in the MLB for some seasons.
    Baseball Trade Page: Hidden Content
    4 Sport Trade Bucket: Hidden Content

  4. #4




    Join Date
    May 2015
    Posts
    1,787
    SCF Rewards
    1,062
    Country
    Pittsburgh Penguins Pittsburgh Pirates Toledo Rockets
    See bigbenjobu's Items on eBay Instagram: Packrip.com Traders

    I went with the Phillies, but think this one is super close

  5. #5
    Football Manager





    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Age
    67
    Posts
    8,483
    SCF Rewards
    92,331
    Transferred Feedback
    Freaks (12)
    Country
    Air Force
    Dallas Cowboys New York Yankees Boston Celtics
    Twitter: @Grampie11 See bakemeister52's Items on eBay COMC Cards For Sale My traders on Flickr

    This close but I think the Phillies I will go with!
    Football: Emmitt Smith, Leighton Vander Esch, 2006 SP Paul McQuistan and Michael Gallup!
    Non-Sports: Star Wars, Silver Surfer, Thor, NCIS
    Baseball: Aaron Judge, Gleyber Torres, Adley Rutschman and Derek Jeter!
    Comics: Star Wars, Silver Silver and Thor
    Want to fill in my Emmitt Smith and Derek Jeter PCs! Let me know what you have for me!!

    Hidden Content

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
SCF Sponsors


About SCF

    Sports Card Forum provides sports and non-sports card collectors a safe place to discuss, buy, sell and trade.

    SCF maintains tools that will allow collectors to manage their collections online, information about what is happening with the hobby, as well as providing robust data to send out for Autographs through the mail.

Follow SCF on