View Poll Results: Better all time 25 man roster

6. This poll is closed
  • Yankees

    4 66.67%
  • Athletics

    2 33.33%
Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Yankees vs Athletics

  1. #1

    Join Date
    Mar 2018
    SCF Rewards
    Anaheim Angels Alabama Crimson Tide Chicago Bears

    Yankees vs Athletics

    Who has a better all time 25 man roster? Who would win if these two teams faced off?


    C: Yogi Berra, Bill Dickey
    1B: Lou Gehrig, Don Mattingly
    2B: Willie Randolph, Tony Lazzeri
    3B: Alex Rodriguez, Graig Nettles
    SS: Derek Jeter, Phil Rizzuto
    LF: Roy White
    CF: Mickey Mantle, Joe Dimaggio, Bernie Williams
    RF: Babe Ruth
    SP: Whitey Ford, Andy Pettitte, Ron Guidry, Red Ruffing, Lefty Gomez
    RP: Mariano Rivera, Dave Righetti, Rich Gossage, Sparky Lyle, David Robertson


    C: Mickey Cochrane, Terry Steinbach
    1B: Jimmie Foxx, Mark McGwire
    This Ad will be removed when you a member of

    2B: Eddie Collins, Max Bishop
    3B: Sal Bando, Home Run Baker
    SS: Bert Campaneris, Eddie Joost
    LF: Rickey Henderson, Bob Johnson
    CF: Al Simmons, Dwayne Murphy
    RF: Reggie Jackson
    SP: Eddie Plank, Lefty Grove, Rube Waddell, Chief Bender, Tim Hudson
    RP: Dennis Eckersly, Rollie Fingers, Eddie Rommel, Justin Duchscherer, Russ Christopher

  2. #2

    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    SCF Rewards
    Baltimore Orioles Washington Nationals

    Personally, I think these teams to be 50/50. In my opinion, if they played 100 games, they'd split 50-50. In a break down I see this ---

    C - slightly Yankees
    1B - A's - more long ball power
    2B- A's - Eddie Collins is the BEST of the four. On the Yankees, I'd remove Randolph and replace him with Bobby Richardson.
    3B- Yankees - due to A Rod.'s hitting power (may not have been if he hadn,'t been on ..........)
    SS- Yankees - because of Jeter
    LF- A's - because of Rickey Henderson
    CF- Yankees - better back-up centerfielder
    RF- Yankees - "Babe", no competition for him
    SP- A's - no 300 game winner in Yankees history. Also, I'd replace Hudson as my 5th SP with Jim "Catfish" Hunter. Pitching seldom,in their entire history,was as impressive as Yankee hitting. It was that "power" hitting that led the Yankees to most of their titles. Also, on these two team SP's, the A's have way too many 300 wins (or more) pitchers for the Yankee hitting line-up.
    RP - An overall even split
    Last edited by OriolesFan; 04-21-2019 at 08:10 PM.

  3. #3

    Join Date
    May 2015
    SCF Rewards
    Pittsburgh Penguins Pittsburgh Pirates Toledo Rockets
    See bigbenjobu's Items on eBay Instagram: Traders

    Very slight edge to the Yankees

  4. #4

    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    SCF Rewards
    See 529mi's Items on eBay

    Randolph ? How about Joe gordon , hofer.?
    Jackson played about the same for both teams

    Relief Johnny Murphy or Joe Page, not robertson

  5. #5

    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    SCF Rewards
    Transferred Feedback
    Freaks (12)
    Air Force
    Dallas Cowboys New York Yankees Boston Celtics
    See bakemeister52's Items on eBay COMC Cards For Sale My traders on Flickr

    The Yankees just a little more than the Athletics!
    Football: Emmitt Smith, Leighton Vander Esch, Michael Gallup, CeeDee Lamb and Pollard!
    Baseball: Aaron Judge, Gleyber Torres and Derek Jeter!
    Comics: Star Wars, Silver Silver and Thor Non-Sports: Star Wars, Silver Surfer, Thor, NCIS
    Hidden Content (Needs updating)

    Want to fill in my Emmitt Smith and Derek Jeter PCs! Let me know what you have for me!!

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
SCF Sponsors

About SCF

    Sports Card Forum provides sports and non-sports card collectors a safe place to discuss, buy, sell and trade.

    SCF maintains tools that will allow collectors to manage their collections online, information about what is happening with the hobby, as well as providing robust data to send out for Autographs through the mail.

Follow SCF on