Results 1 to 10 of 27
-
02-20-2008, 11:27 PM #1
Lets Chat about this!!!!
Ok guys got bored so I thought I would start this thread and see what everyone thinks. I am going to put down who I think was the best rookie on offense and defense in 06-07 and the draft sleeper. Would like to see what others on here think. Bring it on, lets get the ball rolling here. Daniel.
06
Offensive: Vince Young - Brought my Titans back to playoff team.
Honorable Mention: M. Colston - the guy was a beast before the injury late in the season
Sleeper: M. Colston
Defense: Mario Williams - his 07 peformance was spectacular
Honorable Mention: A.J. Hawk - I see this guy being a big name for a while.
07
Offensive: A. Peterson - for obivious reasons
Honorable Mention: M. Lynch - the guy is constant in a struggling offense.
Defense: P. Willis - For a big guy he is fast seen him chase down would be touchdowns from behind quite a few times.
Honorable Mention: M Griffin - I think he is a impact player, smart playmaker that will be good for
years to come.
Sleeper: no idea who this year.
-
-
02-21-2008, 01:45 PM #2
I'm a big vince fan, but he has been terrible so far
-
02-21-2008, 05:23 PM #3
I wouldn't say terrible, I would say he has been average he has played better than other starting QB's in the league.
-
-
02-21-2008, 06:34 PM #4
and that makes him the offensive player of that draft HOW?
and your saying he brought them to the playoffs. I mean I love him (he's the pic on my desktop LOL
) but he did NOTHING to get them to the playoffs
-
02-21-2008, 06:42 PM #5
he had a ok year this year not great, but if Collins had started the whole year we wouldn't have even went to the playoffs.
Last year as a Rookie, I thought he was pretty good, he finished with a pretty good record for a Rookie and we almost made the playoffs if we had just got past those Pats.
-
-
02-21-2008, 06:51 PM #6
since when is this a good year:
9 touchdowns
17 interceptions
71.1 QB rating?
-
02-21-2008, 07:08 PM #7
I was talking about last year, I know this year wasn't great however Collins couldn't have done better. And we did make the playoffs, I know our defense is a big part of that but in my belief they tried to keep Vince in the pocket to much this year and that's not who he is.
-
-
02-21-2008, 07:21 PM #8
Addai is the best offensive player from 06, he won the Colts the Super Bowl last year, and is a top 5 NFL RB...on defense I think Demeco Ryans has to be mentioned as well.
-
02-21-2008, 07:29 PM #9
A little titan biased....?
06
Offensive: I agree Vince Young
Defensive: Demeco Ryans, hes an animal
Sleeper: Devin Hester, come on, where would the bears have been in 06 if it wasnt for him? This past season too for that matter...
Flop (Thought Id add a category): Reggie Bush (Still amazing, just not up to expectations) or vernon davis
07
Offensive: No Doubt AP
Defensive: P. Willis
Sleeper: Kolby Smith Troy Smith or Selvin Young (undrafted)
Flop: John Beck, thats why the dolphins will take matt ryan or Ted Ginn Jr. Good draft dolphins :)
-
02-21-2008, 07:32 PM #10
I agree in sorts with you Addai is really good. There is just something about V. Young I think he will be better once we get a offensive coordinator that knows how to properly utilize him. I think his Rookie Year was pretty good, I do admit he had a rough one this year. Ryans was good as well and I fully agree he does deserve mention. Daniel.
-
Originally Posted by lil5up3rman 
