Top 2008 Rookies?

[BoogieDownBerlin]

what about desean jackson??

[Ryo1549]

what about desean jackson??

Highly touted rookie but not top 5.

[tolrobb3]

Top 5 are D-Mac, Felix Jones, Matt Ryan, Mendenhall, and Flacco.

But it's real close after the top 3....Brohm, J. Stewart, Henne, Sweed, D. Jackson, K. Smith, C.Johnson.....etc. etc.

This class may not have a ton of quality, but the depth is there.

[SPOIL3D]

I really think that Kevin Jones will win back his starting job from Matt Forte.

I'm surprised nobody has mentioned James Hardy. I think he's in the best position to become the best performing WR rookie of the class.

My top five would be Run DMC, Jonathan Stewart, Matt Ryan, Devin Thomas, and James Hardy.

[bmarshallfan]

what about glenn dorsey could be another patrick willis in terms of going up

[JoeFlaccoFan]

In terms of the hobby?

I think it'd have to be
1. McFaddy
2. Matt Ryan
3. Felix Jones
4. Rashard Mendenhall
5. Joe Flacco

that would be my exact order for the top 5 too.

[mack10290]

McFadden and Matt Ryan without a doubt are the top 2. Then theres Kevin Smith, Limas Sweed, Felix Jones, Joe Flacco, Chad Henne, Jonathan Stewart, Ray Rice and so on.

Good list here, but I would add Mendenhall to this group, even though hes gotta hang onto the ball better. His cards are much hotter than Sweeds, I collect them both so I can say that for sure. Flacco has not looked good so far in pre-season. This guy will get playing time because the Ravens are S.O.L. at QB, but I think hes gonna get clobbered. Definately a guy that you'd wanna sell his good cards now because hes gonna have a tough time of it. Henne might have some upside later in the season behind Pennington because Penington will likely miss some time with injuries (hes getting kinda old), and Henne will get a chance to start.