Is this McDonalds All-American Auto FAKE?

[mufinman009]

The sigs on these cards sure look real, but I noticed something fishy about them.

Take a look at the cards, and under the sigs (on the gray and white panel) you can see that they read "2008 McDonald's All-American".

Now take a look and this Jennings I have.
Same year.

This one clearly says "2008 Authentic Autograph Issue".

And I know that Topps also released unsigned versions, like the upper cards.
http://cgi.ebay.com/2008-MCDONALDS-P...item414b19ed8f

Let me know your thoughts. I own the Jennings and Ed Davis by the way.
All help and inputs are appreciated.

Thanks!

[boba]

it was 08 when they autographed those cards, all of them say 08 issue unless im mistaken.

[realreodeal]

it was 08 when they autographed those cards, all of them say 08 issue unless im mistaken.

The original poster means that the tops 6 cards all say 2008 All American and his Jennings says Autograph Issue.

[mufinman009]

Yes thats exactly what I mean. What do you guys think

[boba]

The original poster means that the tops 6 cards all say 2008 All American and his Jennings says Autograph Issue.

oh, my bad, read it to fast

[tarheelsnipe]

interesting. i'd like to see them side by side.

Here's a picture of the regular Ed Davis.

[mufinman009]

Yeah see there's versions like that. So i dont know if maybe some of these versions were signed and some were released unsigned, or if they were all unsigned and mine's a fake? Not sure.

[trevorp121]

I would lean towards fake. Just because the Jennings says Autograph issue while the other doesnt. Does the Davis or Jennings say anything on the back?

[mufinman009]

Theyre exactly the same on the back.

[tarheelsnipe]

I'd stay away from it unless it says auto somewhere on the card. I don't know of any Topps auto cards that don't have some sort of coa on them.