Which 1/1 is better?

[Prime B]

clearly the first one by a long shot. Barrie im surprised that isnt in your PC already? lol

I have actually passed on that card 3 times in the past year because the VERY poorly centered Blake shield. Look at it, it is pretty bad. The first seller solid it to this guy after he couldn't work a deal with me. This seller offered it to me about 4 months ago for $500. I said no because of the badly centered shield. Seems his price keeps dropping................

[burrows14]

I have actually passed on that card 3 times in the past year because the VERY poorly centered Blake shield. Look at it, it is pretty bad. The first seller solid it to this guy after he couldn't work a deal with me. This seller offered it to me about 4 months ago for $500. I said no because of the badly centered shield. Seems his price keeps dropping................

ya thats the only reason whys im asking os because the centering is off

[TheIronHorse4]

Seems like because of the poor centering you can get a solid deal on a card with two very good players. So long as you don't mind the defect, seems like a solid pick-up

[HammerHawks]

Seems like because of the poor centering you can get a solid deal on a card with two very good players. So long as you don't mind the defect, seems like a solid pick-up

+1

Johnson will be really good, plus it's a RC year card of him too. Go with the first one, especially since Barrie doesn't want it.

[Vancollects25]

I believe that the Blake/Johnson Dual 1/1 is definately better the the other.

[gomaz]

im thinking of buying one, which one do you guys think i should get?
http://cgi.ebay.ca/07-08-the-cup-blake-johnson-dual-shield-1-1_W0QQitemZ190383326431QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUS_Hocke y_Trading_Cards?hash=item2c53bb04df#ht_500wt_1182
OR
http://cgi.ebay.ca/07-08-the-cup-samsonov-khabibulin-dual-shield-1-1_W0QQitemZ190383327296QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUS_Hocke y_Trading_Cards?hash=item2c53bb0840#ht_500wt_1182
LMK!!!

Since it obviously won't stay in your collection for very long (because you have to ask other people which one you should buy) I would go for the Blake/Johnson card as it will have higher long term value.

And I've seen UD staffers center shields with their bare hands at card shows just by applying pressure to it in the direction you want it to go. Should be as easy as faking a patch card.