Top 5 Postwar Position Players?

[mcgoo2]

I'm putting together a piece involving some signed items by the top players of the postwar era. Right now I have a plaque signed by Mays and Mantle, a Ted Williams signed baseball, and a Joe Dimaggio signed baseball. I'm patiently waiting for the perfect Musial signed baseball. My dilemma is whether I should go for an Aaron and Bonds or not.

I would obviously like to include bonds and aaron as I believe that would make the definitive top 7 of the postwar era (steroid issues aside) however, I'm curious as to what everyone else thinks. Putting aside the steroid issue, are these 2 players in your top 5 or are they just part of that almighty 2nd Tier? Or, am I forgetting someone all-together?


The more replies the better!

Thanks.

[Qwikflipz]

Putting aside Steriods. Bonds should be up there.

[Star_Cards]

aaron and bonds would be in my top tier list.

[mcgoo2]

Thanks for the replies. I agree but I was just curious as to what everyone thought. Anybody I am missing that you would regard as "Top Tier" or is this pretty clear cut?