which is a better buy?

[dxco00]

I am looking at purchasing two of these cards (lost out on a malkin ARP auction recently);

Justin Pogge the cup /99 (2 clrs)
Blake Wheeler the cup /99 (2clrs)
Jonas Hiller the cup /249 (white clr)
Sam Gagner the cup/ 99 (3 clrs)

I cant decide which 2 shud I get? Thanks for you input!

[mugatu471]

I'd go with the Gagner and the Wheeler. My reasoning is...they'll sell better and will have better trade value. If the other two are PC and the other's aren't then go with them. Just my .02

[Smashy77]

Same here. I'll go with Gagner and Wheeler. Pogge doesn't have a great value (in my mind) and Hiller has a plain white patch (which I totally don't like). Gagner and Wheeler are multicolored and out of 99. Great to have. Good luck with your chase. Thanks, Annie

[RGM81]

I'd go with the Gagner and the Wheeler. My reasoning is...they'll sell better and will have better trade value. If the other two are PC and the other's aren't then go with them. Just my .02

Agree. Pogge doesn't look to have much of a future in the NHL and while Hiller will, he's on a team that doesn't attract much love.

[Pata93]

Why not a Voracek? :)

Seriously, I agree with everybody here. Go with the Gagner and Wheeler.

[dxco00]

Thanks! that helps alot. I kinda want a Price or a Malkin cup /99 rc but none r available right now. Hate the offseason hah

[dxco00]

Why not a Voracek? :)

Seriously, I agree with everybody here. Go with the Gagner and Wheeler.

I have the Voracek already hah :D

[marekschwarz33]

I would stick with the Gagner and Wheeler. Pogge will be an NHL backup at best and although Hiller is a good goalie, the 1 color swatch detracts from the card imo.

[BeeZeR]

POGGE. Get it cheap before he turns into a HOF goaltender..... lol I can dream right?

[HammerHawks]

I agree with everyone else, Gagner and Wheeler for sure.

OR, you can just wait for a Malkin to pop up. ;)