Successes:

Jeremy Hellickson
Dustin Ackley
Curtis Granderson

Autopens (not sure whether to group these as successes or failures):

Roy Halladay
Robin Yount

Pending:
Starlin Castro
Chris Carter (Oak)
Pedro Alvarez
Chipper Jones
Joey Votto
Yovani Gallardo
Josh Hamilton
Charlie Manuel
Kurt Warner
Frank Gore
Chad Ochocinco
Adam Wainwright
Mike Leake
Austin Jackson
Tedy Bruschi
Archie Manning
Mike Singletary
John Kruk
Matt Schaub
Dallas Clark
Bobby Doerr
Yogi Berra