Does this devalue the card?

[BayAreaWarrior]

What impact on card value does something like this have? This seller is selling an official autographed card, with an in person autograph on the back. Does this hurt or improve the card value?

http://cgi.ebay.com/Rodney-Stuckey-U...item35b1686d2b

[MeloJrsyCllctr]

Hurt.

[eddiejr]

yeah it definitely doesnt help the value, if anything its a real cool, oddballish addition to a Stuckey collector

[mrveggieman]

I wouldn't buy it because the autograph on the back is not certified.

[eddiejr]

yeah but the front one is & theres really no reason for the person to fake an auto on the back since it in no way raises the value of the card

[LeicesterBladex]

id say it devalues the card .. but if you collect stuckey, its a real nice addition i guess :)

[CamaroPat]

Hmm, thats just wierd, I can see getting a jersey or even patch card signed in person, but why a card already auto'd, lol. Id agree with everybody else here and say it lowers the value just because the 2nd auto doesnt have a coa and it is signed over the first "coa". Id say it isnt faked because he has no reason to fake it, but it is quite odd he'd get that card signed in person.

[BayAreaWarrior]

Thanks for the responses, I'm going to have to think about it. May go for it and get it PSA at a convention, just because its unique to have to autos. Would getting it PSA authenticated help maybe?

[teacheric]

A COA from PSA/DNA or other reputable 3rd party will "save" the value of the card or slightly increase it.

[520DAVEAZ]

it hurts the card