Results 1 to 7 of 7
-
05-26-2011, 09:16 PM #1
Would this be fair to ask?
I just picked up a Skinner Silhouette /25. One just sold on bay for $560.
I just need a Hall Silhouette to complete my set (already have a Skinner /99).
Given the recent sale of the Skinner would it be fair to ask for a straight up trade for a Hall?
Don't want to lowball anybody so seeking feedback.
Thanks all.
-
-
05-26-2011, 09:20 PM #2
It's fair to ask anything you want. It's just as fair for anyone to say no. Try it and see what happens then you'll know for sure.
-
05-26-2011, 10:48 PM #3
qwas couldn't have said it better, but i think its a pretty fair offer. sale value looks like it's in the same area for both, someone would probably do it if they really wanted the Skinner. wouldn't hurt to throw it out there and see what ur options are.
-
-
05-26-2011, 11:48 PM #4
yeah i think its fair enough...maybe the guy like Skinner too...ya never know
Please check my inventory before my photobucket!!! It's more up to date!!!
Looking for LPGA GOLFERS and BUFFALO SABRES
Hidden Content
Hidden Content
Top Want: 2012 Leaf Metal Anna Nordqvist Award Winners Prism Gold 1/1
-
05-27-2011, 05:20 PM #5
It really says a lot that you wanted to get some consensus on whether a deal bordered on low-balling when it's already such a reasonable one. Kudos...
-
-
05-27-2011, 09:06 PM #6
Who cares if the offer is good.
You would be making a mistake trading that patch /25 for a jersey /99.
The patches will ALWAYS be the more desirable card in my mind.
And don't hate me, but Skinner is also probably going to be the better player too in the long run.
-
05-27-2011, 09:59 PM #7
Thanks guys, appreciate the feedback.
The reason I put it out there is I took a lot of heat for a post months back about seeking a Stamkos Ice. Many got their panties in a bunch so I figured I would do the safe thing and just get feedback first.
Kovy - can't say I disagree. Appreciate your candor.
-
