What feedback would you leave?

**habscards** · 10-23-2011, 07:36 PM

Long story short is this. I had made a trade thread up about a month ago on here, HI and CnC. I made a trade with someone from CnC and this is what happened.

So a member asked me about a Jonathan Blum H+P auto.

I then went through their trade list and listed about ten cards of theirs that I like.

A Luke Adam Contenders auto rookie was on the list and the guy said that he would do that trade.

I am a new member on that site and had to send first. I send first and I got positive feedback.

I wait two weeks or so and get a Cory Schneider YG in the mail from the trader.

I message the guy saying that he sent the wrong card. He then told me that when we made the trade he did not have it in hand yet. I was not aware of this at the time of the trade. So he sent me a Schneider YG instead.

Now I ask him about the Luke Adam and he said that his cards are selling well now and does not want to do that trade anymore.

After me telling him that we had a deal and he received his card already he cannot back out now. So he then says that if I send the Schneider back to him that he will send the Luke Adam.

So now I have to pay to ship his card back that was the wrong card that he sent on purpose.

I know that it may not deserve a negative but I feel as if they have been really shady with me.

**iamthej** · 10-23-2011, 07:46 PM

Definately a negative... They are a scanner! If you don't do it, then others will not know what he has done, and may continue to do it to others!

Just my 2 cents...

**samwright1961** · 10-23-2011, 07:46 PM

i am not sure why your asking this question, leave him a negative feedback so no else has to deal with his dishonesty

**GHCHambone** · 10-23-2011, 07:46 PM

In my opinion, that deserves a negative. He didn't tell you the card was incoming, and he sends you an different card and wants you to send it back for the card he was supposed to send? That is not how a trade should go at all.

**jim bradt** · 10-23-2011, 07:50 PM

Negative feedback for sure.

**pur3strpker0** · 10-23-2011, 08:09 PM

Negative feedback is appropriate as Im pretty sure somewhere in the rules state that if you don not have the card in hand you are not allowed to ask the trader to send until the they have the card in hand.