Fair Deal?

[roaddogg02316]

Got something going with someone who likes to use Sale Value rather than BV.

I like the Hamill($20 value)

He likes my Biron($15 value and Tverdovsky $12 value) He's putting $10 on Oleg and $6-8 for Biron as his sale values.

My only issue is this fair enough? I think the Tverdovsky is a really cool piece. right off the shoulder patch.

I do collect Bruins so maybe I'll just cave and do the deal despit the oleg being nice.

[cygnusx1]

I'd do that trade. While he's probably underestimating the value of the Tverdovsky, he's also overestimating the Biron. In the end it evens out and you're getting:

a) One valuable card for two less-valuable cards
b) A card that will be more attractive to pretty much anyone over the other cards as it is much more recent
c) A card for your PC.

Win-win!

[Fred Bear]

I'd do that trade. While he's probably underestimating the value of the Tverdovsky, he's also overestimating the Biron. In the end it evens out and you're getting:

a) One valuable card for two less-valuable cards
b) A card that will be more attractive to pretty much anyone over the other cards as it is much more recent
c) A card for your PC.

Win-win!

I agree, this shouldn't even really be a question, especially if the Hamill's going in your PC.

To be honest, you'd make out swapping the Biron and Tverdovsky for just about any single card produced in the last couple of years with a BV of $20-25... The Tverdovsky is nice, but neither it or the Biron are particularly hard to find (and a $15 BV on the Biron is an artifact of days gone by).

[roaddogg02316]

Yeah I'll probably just do it. I also kind of think of Hamill as a waste anymore. He isn't going to make it in the big time anymore I don't think. Probably just too attached to the Oleg, that is a cool piece. Maybe I'll find an even better couple of cards like that but in Bruins down the road.

[30ranfordfan]

Looks pretty fair to me.