Got my redemption replacements back

[bdp1999]

Could you please help me out with this. These are the cards that they replaced. Which group has the higher value?

Redemptions
(3) Marc Gasol 08-09 /33 Jsy Exq.
(1) Marc Gasol Exquisite Autographs 08-09 /35
(1) Marc Gasol 08-09 /150 Exq.
(1) Marc Gasol 08-09 /299 Radiance
(1) Rudy Fernandez 08-09 /225 Exq.
(2) Kyle Weaver 08-09 /20 Jsy Exq.
(1) Brandon Rush 08-09 /225 Exq.

Replacements
(1) Nolan Smith Home Court Signatures
(1) Nolan Smith SP Authentic Sig.
(1) Klay Thompson /50 Rookie F/X SP Authentic Sig.
(1) Klay Thompson /25 SP Authentic Sig.
(1) Klay Thompson SP Authentic Sig.
(1) MarShon Brooks /25 SP Authentic Sig.
(1) MarShon Brooks SP Authentic Sig.
(1) Sonny Weems/Donte Greene UD Black /5 08-09 Daul RC
(1) Sonny Weems/Donte Greene UD Black /10 08-09 Daul RC
(1) James Harden Greats of the Game Glory Days /10 Sig. 09-10?
(1) Rajon Rondo UD Premier Premier Penmanship /50 07-08
(1) R. Westbrook/D. Gallinari/B. Rush Exquisite 07-08 RC Sig. /199

Was this an even swap?

[Frantiic]

we are not allowed to post BV's on the site. get a subscription on beckett.com, its farily cheap aswell.

[Frantiic]

but, i think you did pretty good anyways. the triple rookie auto is sweeit, so is the Harden auto..

[Mike13198]

WOW! Nice Replacements ! I'd say that was a very good swap!

[bdp1999]

Thanks!

[fireice113]

Personally I think it was a great swap, good job!!!

[jprt80]

+1, I think you did really well. Klay thompson was getting hott late in the season and marshon brooks seems to be doing pretty well add in the triple auto and a rondo auto. I think you got the better end of that one.

[BigAl_83]

Did you redeem 3x 08-09 Exquisite M.Gasol /33 auto-patches?
Those Klay Thompsons definitely sell very well, but if you look at how few Marc Gasol autos are available and what they sell for, imagine what those Exquisite RC year auto-patches would sell for?

Plus what would bug me is that you redeemed cards of the most expensive and best possible high-end product with those players in their nba uniform.
The best replacements are the Thompsons and Harden and are all in college uniform, which would be a huge bummer for me. But thats just how i would feel.

From a value standpoint it might be a good deal, but to me collecting is more than just values. To me the appeal of a card is also important. I would much rather have those M.Gasol Exquisite patch-autos than a few high-selling Klay Thompsons in college uni.

[bdp1999]

yeah, that's how I felt but UD only matches by beckett price and a list of player you want. They also told me that I wouldn't get any cards that were under a year old. As you can see most of them that I have are. As i keep thinking about it, I think i still did ok.