Good replacement?

[Frantiic]

hi!

Been waiting for a redemption since 17 dec, a Ben Gordon / Isiah Thomas 10/11 black box dual passing the torch/ logoman auto /10.

Been waiting for 7 months, and today they sent a replacement.

Its a Isiah Thomas Panini Preferred Panini's choice gold auto/10 . Is it a good replacement or not?

I think it is. Ben Gordon is my PC so its sad i will never get that card. wonder if it will ever be made.

thoughts?

[magic_bobcat]

Aww gutted dude.

It probably is a good replacement, if you want to move it on because some people prefer Legends autos on their own. But as a PC replacement its nowhere near good enough haha.

At least you've got something I've seen people on here waiting for 2 years or more.

[Frantiic]

yeah it sucks, was really looking forward getting that card. i dont really like the design of it, but it would be my first dual auto.

BUt i guess i can get some cash for the replacement though. not alot of these cards have been up on ebay, but the card #ed to 25 sold for 25 and 29, and the card #ed to 20 went for a bit over 30. so i guess i can make my money back that i spent on the redemption.

[Frantiic]

finally got it in today, and its damaged on the back :( this sucks. . what to do now?

[magic_bobcat]

That sucks dude. Ive never done a replacement so I can't offer any advice sorry.

[Frantiic]

i tweeted the CSM on twitter, and he asked me to send it back, and that he will compensate me for the postage :)

[Italy61587]

i think it was a bad replacement anyways. i'd be upset if i pulled a dual auto and it got replaced by a single auto. if they're gonna send you singles they should either send you two or if they're gonna send you one single it should be of higher value than the original card as a sorry for not fulfilling the redemption

[Frantiic]

i think it was a bad replacement anyways. i'd be upset if i pulled a dual auto and it got replaced by a single auto. if they're gonna send you singles they should either send you two or if they're gonna send you one single it should be of higher value than the original card as a sorry for not fulfilling the redemption

i think the replacement i got have a bit higher value, i overpaid for the card in the first place. a battle between me and some other guy. but yeh, i hear you.

i hope i get something different back, the postage with tracking back to panini will cost me more than the card is worth =/

Im not sure if i should keep it the way it is.. here's a scan of the back, could've been messed up when Isiah signed it. it kind of peeled back:/ the corners are a bit white aswell... i like it that they shipped it in a magnetic, but it moves a bit inside, so could be from the shipping .. i prefer a pennysleeve and a toploader with a bit of tape to keep it rigid and safe, magnetics tends to throw the cards around, especially when its a die-cut.


'

Robin