Legit?

[cmcalister21]

Is the card listed for sale on this Ebay auction legitimate and authentic?
http://cgi.ebay.com/CHRIS-MCALISTER-...QQcmdZViewItem

Edited to fix link.

[envoy98]

Hmm...he sold a Torry Holt and has the Katzenmoyer and McAllister up for auction now. The autos are legit, but I don't remember the red autos being numbered, especially hand numbered. Seems to me I just saw one of these not too long ago and one was printed in black on the back and the other (black ink) was not numbered at all. I think this guy might have hand written the "1 of 1" on the back. That being said, if that is the case, I would bid accordingly. My thought is that the red ink is more scarce but seems to me they were just short printed, not 1/1. Someone else may know for certain.

[cmcalister21]

Hmm...he sold a Torry Holt and has the Katzenmoyer and McAllister up for auction now. The autos are legit, but I don't remember the red autos being numbered, especially hand numbered. Seems to me I just saw one of these not too long ago and one was printed in black on the back and the other (black ink) was not numbered at all. I think this guy might have hand written the "1 of 1" on the back. That being said, if that is the case, I would bid accordingly. My thought is that the red ink is more scarce but seems to me they were just short printed, not 1/1. Someone else may know for certain.

Thanks! So it is most likely not an 1/1, right?

[OGLESBYC]

if it was stamped 1 of 1 the first one wouldnt be that much longer than the second one i would say that it is not legit i would love to turn idiots like this in people that ruin the hobby for an extra buck is bs

[cmcalister21]

I emailed the seller. I'll see what his reply will be.......

[Romulusvex]

Thanks! So it is most likely not an 1/1, right?

It looks as though the owner of the card wrote the 1/1 on the Top loader his/herself. The card appears not to be a 1/1, if you are very interested in bidding ask the seller where exactly the 1/1 is written, and if you could get a better descrition, and a scan of the card back itself, no top loader

[cmcalister21]

It looks as though the owner of the card wrote the 1/1 on the Top loader his/herself. The card appears not to be a 1/1, if you are very interested in bidding ask the seller where exactly the 1/1 is written, and if you could get a better descrition, and a scan of the card back itself, no top loader

Thanks, I'll do just that.

[rayny1]

Looks like the guy got a hold of some clearance items from Collector`s Edge. I looked up the card on Beckett and it comes up with N/A value although it doesn`t state wether or not it is a 1/1. Maybe Edge never released these cards. I see he also has up on eBay a Shaun Alexander Rookie Ink that isn`t signed. Also has lots of "Media Release Only" cards. Who knows? I don`t like the way 1 of 1 looks on the back. I`d be a little cautious here. I guess if you won it for $19.99 it wouldn`t be too bad. The auto looks good.

[cmcalister21]

I emailed the seller and he's stating that the card is authentic.

[YaoFan11]

the card is authentic but dont think its a 1 of 1. I did have a similar card from edge but was peerless price. the seriall # was printed on the back though. i would beware.