opinions please

[JPDSPORTSCARDS]

Does this sound like a good trade???

Crosby FWA BGS 9.5,
SOT8-GR8 (Gretzky, Lemieux, Messier, Sakic, Orr, Coffey, Brodeur, Roy),
2011-12 SP Authentic Gretzky Limited Auto Patch (All-Star) /10

for

The Cup Ryan Nugent-Hopkins RC /99 3 Color Patch/auto

LMK what you all think
Jason

[adamslogik]

Personally, I would hold onto the stuff on top.

If you are planning on selling the RNH immediately, then it's a good deal, you'll make money.

If you are planning on holding onto it, the Gretzky stuff will ALWAYS hold it's value, whereas the RNH may decline in value.

[Fred Bear]

I would no longer own a RNH Cup ARP if it was my decision. [My decision assumes that no redemptions are involved.]

[Yipper]

Bye Bye Nuge!

[TMLxCrosby87]

You didn't specify which cards you are getting but if you own the nuge, accept the trade NOW!!

[MattDMC]

Crosby FWA BGS 9.5,
SOT8-GR8 (Gretzky, Lemieux, Messier, Sakic, Orr, Coffey, Brodeur, Roy),
2011-12 SP Authentic Gretzky Limited Auto Patch (All-Star) /10


I would take these in a heart beat if all it was costing me was a Nuge Cup rookie

[mikepro44]

I would agree....Bye Nuge

[reoddai]

I would also trade away that nuge.

Cheers,
reoddai

[Statmoe]

lol

No love for the Nuge?!

[Mozesmadness]

I am extremely biased but I would keep the Nuge

It will be worth double one day

Just my opinion though