Well I wasn't expecting much considering I redeemed only one card (Rich Harden GU/Auto).

Here's what they sent:
Jose Cruz, Jr. '97 Skybox auto- pretty much the ugliest card I've ever seen- it looks fake
Ben Sheets-2004 Fleer Ultra Season Crowns Jersey
Mike Mussina-2001 Fleer Platinum National Patch Time Jersey

Like I said, I wasn't expecting much but I'd rather have had the Harden. At least they followed through though.