What would you grade this?!?

[Fleener]

Sending this in for a BGS sudmission. HHoping for a 10 auto and 9.5 overal. There is one hairline scratch, in one spot. About a centimeter long. It's only noticeable if you put it in the light and have a magnifying glass. Will this affect anything? If so, please let me know your opinion!



All corners are perfect too..

how about this contenders one, what would you grade it, there's a little white on two left corners other than that the card is pristine. What would you grade it?

[morganboys]

I would say the autos on both will end up 10's. they will notice the scratch on the prestige which could push surface to a 9. if all three other areas grade 9.5 you should still be ok for your 9.5. however if any of the others dip to a 9 or the surface to an 8.5 you're looking at a 9. The contenders has a pretty rough top left corner and if there are any surface issues at all the chance of 9.5 are slim. if these are cards in your pc I wouldn't hesitate to send them in. If you are grading to sell I wouldn't grade the contenders.

[Fleener]

I would say the autos on both will end up 10's. they will notice the scratch on the prestige which could push surface to a 9. if all three other areas grade 9.5 you should still be ok for your 9.5. however if any of the others dip to a 9 or the surface to an 8.5 you're looking at a 9. The contenders has a pretty rough top left corner and if there are any surface issues at all the chance of 9.5 are slim. if these are cards in your pc I wouldn't hesitate to send them in. If you are grading to sell I wouldn't grade the contenders.

yeah these are strictly for my PC, but I'd like a 9.5 on my osweilers. There aren't any surface issues on the contenders only that upper left corner issue. The scratch on the prestige will hopefully hold the grade of 9.5. Thanks for your input!