Which case should I order? You decide!

[robinson4me]

I'm torn between either a case "6 boxes" of 12-13 All Time Greats, or 1 case "15 boxes" of 10-11 Ultimate Collection. ATG has a guaranteed MJ auto per case and I've had sick luck with this product. Ultimate Collection has the shot at MJ, dual, triple, and quad autos, but has the possibility of expired redemptions which UD will not honor. I'm leaning towards the ATG but I'm not sure yet.

[wmaguire]

i am partial tot he ultimate, but thats because my only jordan auto was pulled from that set, but since UD wont honor the expired redemption and the exp redemption program they have had yielded some terrible returns, id have to say go with the ATG.

[robinson4me]

I had some solid luck with Ultimate. I broke 10 boxes and pulled a Paul George Ultimate Rookie auto, James Harden auto, Tracy McGrady silver all time draft auto #'d /5. No redemptions!! lol

[WilyWestbrook0]

ATG would seem the best bet for you based on that info and experience.

[robinson4me]

Good point, I think I'll just do that. Better checklist too and I'd had to get a redemption. I was looking at breaks on youtube and some unlucky fellow pulled a dual auto of MJ/Magic Johnson. OUCH!

[robinson4me]

Ended up ordering the last box of 10-11 Ultimate Collection from CharmCityCards (I hate leaving 1 or 2 packs or the last box of something). Also ordered a 6 box case of ATG and a 6 box case of Black from Steel City Collectibles today.

[pwaldo]

I'd say to go with All Time Greats just because of the redemption thing. That is a big issue for older products. Not that I blame Upper Deck for not accepting them since they are expired but product like this should go DOWN in price because of the risk of getting burned by an expired redemption card.