Vintage question about checklists

[mrecoskie]

Hi,

Looking for some SCF wisdom.

For older card checklists -
Assuming similar cards ... is it better to have a creased unmarked checklist or a marked checklist?

Looking for opinions. Sorry if the answer appears somewhere else.

Thanks,

\Mark

[Tripredacus]

Value wise, an unmarked checklist would be preferred. Personally I like marked ones, or cards with writing on them because it gives them personality or some history with whoever had once owned them in the past.

[30ranfordfan]

Hard for me to say without looking at the card. Depends on the marks, depends on the creases.


I would much rather have the unmarked checklist, with a very light crease.... but if you've got one that's marked and is otherwise near flawless.. compared to an unmarked one with major crease issues.... I dunno?? I would have to see the two to say which one I like better.

[Drewk86a]

Collectors look for unmarked. The only way I am getting unmarked vintage checklists is if I buy new packs. Don't think I have a single checklist from the 80's that I didn't mark, highlight or write on.