would you make this trade?

[redmac04]

ok i have been offered this trade. what should i do and do you think its good trade?

i give up

03 Sage Larry Johnson Auto Bronze Rookie Card #A23
06 Donruss Threads Carson Palmer College Gridiron Kings Framed Card
#CGK-27 (010/100)
06 Donruss Threads Johnny Rodger College Gridiron Kings Auto Card
#CGK-17 – Former Heisman Winner
06 Topps Frank Walker Auto Card #T-FW
06 Donruss Threads Carnell Williams Pro Gridiron Kings Framed Card
#PGK-5 (21/25)
06 Donruss Threads Peyton Manning/Eli Manning Generations Jersey Card
#G-16 (099/250)


i recieve

06 topps 8306 jersey
Absolute memorabilia Marks of Fame parallel #4/25


good trade or bad trade? let me know asap. thanks.

[Shinino]

Jersey and Marks of Fame of who?

And...it doesn't look that good at the moment, but then again, we don't know the BV of most of that stuff.

[redmac04]

the cards i am getting are of vince young. i would think the absolute is worth at least the price of the larry johnson auto.

[Shinino]

Yeah, but I don't know if the 8306 jersey is as worth as much as everything else. But hey, I don't know.

[redmac04]

thanks shinino - anybody else got any thoughts.

[bravesfan09]

personally i wouldnt do it

[redmac04]

what do you think the absolute young card #/25 is worth?

[Vick_All_The_Way]

it's probably not priced...but I would NOT do that trade...I don't think it's a good deal...but you do collect young...so...it's up to you.

[jedijohnson]

The Vince Young Marks of Fame is an auto/jersey, right?
If so, yeah...I'd do it.

[colts18328887]

It's a crap shoot. If Vince pans out its a great deal. If not then well I think you get the picture. If I collected Vince I probably would do it.