How did I do? Do I break seal?

[waf]

So today I got the first of my 3 Upper Deck replacement packages.

I had sent in a rough edged Cole Caufield young guns. Had to go tracked but they offer equivalent in replacement cards for the shipping fees.

They returned a beautiful looking Cole Caulfield young guns. ! for 1 swap
Then they added a Credentials Rookie Science Autograph of Noah Dobson.. NYI

Seems pretty decent as they do not guarantee same cards back for what you send in. Really happy I got a Caufield bac.

Both cards I got have an Upper Deck seal/sticker along the top edge. Do I break them or leave them alone. Caufield I believe is worth grading.

[RGM81]

That's good to hear they were able to swap your Caufield YG and add in a nice little bonus like that. I would say keep the seal on it unless & until you submit for grading.

[doniceage]

Congrats, on the good fortune.

DON

[waf]

That's good to hear they were able to swap your Caufield YG and add in a nice little bonus like that. I would say keep the seal on it unless & until you submit for grading.

This is what I was thinking.

Congrats, on the good fortune.

Thank you.
Hope my other 2 cases get solved the same way.
Next up should be a Caufield and 18 other young guns. Then a Caufield with 6 young guns and some OPC glossy. Needless to say I had good luck pulling Caufield but not quality ones. Most of the young guns came from Walmart mega blasters and the ones with the Jumbo young guns. Pulled 4 Jumbo young guns of Caufield

DON

[30ranfordfan]

Great trade, IMO. They print so many of those YGs, no reason tthey shouldn't be able to give you the same card back (and then to toss in a bonus, that's good customer service).

I don't think the seal adds any value, but I'd probably just leave them in (unless grading)