Big Trade at a card show - How did I do?

[chipperhank44]

OK so I went to a card show on Saturday and went to a couple dealers I know who are cool to trade with. I think I did alright, especially for trading with dealers, but the more I think about it the more I question my judgement. LMK if you think I got a good deal on these trades. Thanks for the help - Trey

Trade 1

I got - Matt Leinart Press Pass Auto /50
Sage Hit Vince Young Auto /100

He Got - Leather & Lumber Nolan Ryan 3 clr Patch /25
Absolute Willie Mays dual JSY /175
Upper Deck Barry Bonds GU Ball
8-10 topps chrome rookies (3rd round and below)

Trade 2

I got - Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Auto

He Got - Donruss Signature Cal Ripken Jr. Auto

[pr0phet]

If your a peyton fan or know somebody that you can easily trade the Peyton too, you did great there. Its hard to justify a star/hof material player like Ripken for somebody still playing((he gets hurt and is out for the rest of his career for some reason, card loses value))

In the first trade you did fairly well to. I would have been quite impressed if those cards were not sage/press pass but still, trading jerseys for autos like that is always nice.

Jay

[Greenbeans]

i think theyre both great trades

ryan's stuff has been in the crapper for a long time (i dont care what beckett says) as far as real value goes. jersey have dropped below $10, so its a patch. you just got two autos of the top two rookie quarterbacks this year.

the other trade is solid, but i actually liked the first one better

[nt4275]

wow that first one was sick for you IMO

and personally i woulda done the second one too, PM me if the peyton manning auto is FT and if you like anything from my bucket

[cubs fan!]

I think you got a steal on the first one and a decent deal on the 2nd!
Mike

[chipperhank44]

Thanks for the feedback guys. I usually try not to trade HOF for rookies (rookie autos are my ultimate weakness), but these deals seemed to be well worth it. These cards are NFT right now, the Leinart is most likely to be tradeable. Thanks again for the reassurance! - Trey

[bravesfan09]

first one was great no doubt!

second one id be extremely picky on the manning

[jaderock]

Agree with most...1st was a good deal...2nd is even trade

[gosoxx777]

personally i think he got the better deal on the second one the reasons being
#1 im a baseball collector
however if i think you got a good deal for a football collector :)

[11chaos]

I liked the first one but I couldn't trade the Ripken unless I had a second one. If you decide to trade the Leinhart lmk not that I have any baseball for ya but I would like to try anyway.