Would you do this trade?

[CubFan777]

I get:
Vince Young 06 Press Pass Blue Rookie Auto #/50 $250


He Gets:
2006 Fleer Showcase Ernie Sims AU BV $20
2006 Turkey Red 4x6 Maroney GU/AU BV $100
2001 Press Pass Ladanian Tomlinson AU BV $135

[Insane Irish]

Just me, but i wouldn't give up the L.T. and Maroney for a press pass auto.

[11chaos]

A lot of people don't appreciate press pass but if you are happy do it. I would think twice about trading LT though, he's a monster. That is unless you have other LT autos laying around.

[CubFan777]

Just me, but i wouldn't give up the L.T. and Maroney for a press pass auto.

Ya thats what I was thinking. Even though the Lt is a Press Pass.BUT IDK

[CubFan777]

A lot of people don't appreciate press pass but if you are happy do it. I would think twice about trading LT though, he's a monster. That is unless you have other LT autos laying around.

I dont really know if I am happy with it.I mlooking to get my higher-end stuff flowing but ya I will probably go buy another LT RC AU somewhere.

[bearfield]

actually, i think the bigger card should get an advantage, especially if trading 3 for 1. and i think more than $5. the LT is a monster, but-----do what you want.
i also don't think any vince young is worth $250. just my opinion.

[duane1969]

Considering the LT is a Press Pass as well that is a push. If you are going to bash the Young for being a PP then you have to bash the LT for the same reasons.

The Maroney and Sims are nothing rare or special so basically you have to decide what means more to you, the Young or LT.

You can pick up another Sims and Maroney on eBay for around $40-$50 dlvd for both so IMO you are essentially giving $40 and the LT for the Young. IMO that is a no-brainer, the Young is well worth it.

Unless the Chargers win a Super Bowl or three and LT sets a few more records, that LT auto will never go up in value. The Young has a huge upside and potential for increase.

If it was me I would have already done the trade.

[JeRmZ]

I would say NO. Your giving up a little too much in my opinion ...........





now check your PM's!

[fact81]

i dont personally have that BS bias that if an Auto is SAGE or Press Pass, dont do the trade, cause thats just stupid,

An Auto is an auto, signed by the same guy on a different piece of cardboard or paper... PERIOD, its stupid to think otherwise, thats just my opinion

As far as the trade goes, I wouldnt let a future HOF'er such as Tomlinson who has had an amazing 6 yr career thus far for a 2nd year guy like Vince Young who besides his winning attitude, didnt impress my all THAT much

Rob

[JayJagFan]

Let me put this simply for you: no.