Results 1 to 10 of 65
-
07-11-2007, 10:14 PM #1
Harry Potter 7...whats your thoughts?
I was just wondering on waht your guys/ladies theories are on what will happen in the 7th book. Personnally I believe that:
Dumbledore is a dark wizard. I have reasons to support this. At the end of the fourth book Crouch Jr says to either harry or Dumbledore you show yours Ill show you mine and reveals his dark mark. Obviously hes talking to Dumbledore because Harry obviously isnt a dark wizard. Next Dumbledore always trusted Snape. Snape has always been a death eater. Therefore they are both death eaters. At the end of the 6th book Dumbledore has a nice chat with Draco. This could have been set up or not but one thing I believe is certain. It is no coincedence that death eaters were able to enter the castle without the Dumbledore being there. Dumbledore knew. Thats why he took Harry looking for the horcrux. So they would have time to enter the castle.
I also have a reason for why Dumbledore helped Harry defeat the horcruxes or atleast try. This is the same reason that Voldemort fears dumbledore. Dumbledore was trying to take over as the greatest dark wizard. Make sense? Please if you like challenge my theory or share your own.
-
-
07-11-2007, 11:17 PM #2
Im going to post so I can suscribe to this thread becasue I have something to say about it lol
-
07-12-2007, 02:16 AM #3
I agree with everything you said nflcardlover...that all makes sense...and i would not doubt it a bit.
-
-
07-12-2007, 12:55 PM #4
That makes no sense.
Look at it this way. If Dumbledore was a dark wizard, he could have killed Harry ANY TIME.
-
07-12-2007, 02:04 PM #5
Originally Posted by Shinino
Yes but think about it this way. On the prophecy it says Harry had to kill voldemort so then Dumbledore was going to wait with Harry until Harry killed voldemort so then Dumbledore could take over as the greatest dark wizard.
Also Dumbledore isnt dead. In the series the avada kedavra simply kills a person on impact, they dont go flying or get cut or anything. Supposedly Dumbledore was hit by an avada kedavra but goes flying 20 feet in the air? Dont think so.
-
-
07-12-2007, 02:38 PM #6
I think Im going to go back and readt the books 4,5,6 again and then I will have a better statement on this but right now I say Dumbledore isnt dead but is not a Dark Wizard
-
07-12-2007, 02:52 PM #7 Originally Posted by CubFan777
Ive read 4,5,6 in the past two weeks. I saw a lot o things I never noticed before. If anyone hasnt seen it the owner and a few of his friends of a harry potter fan site wrote a book on their speculations of what will happen in the 7th book. It was fairly interesting.
Also I just watched the 5th movie last night and there was two statements that wereent in the book that might could tell what the 7th book beholds. Sirius says to harry in the black family tree room, "In the end the family will be all back together." Pretty much meaning Harry will be with his parents and sirius and so on and then Luna says, "Everything always comes together in the end." which could mean the same. I just thought it was weird that this wasnt in the book. Great movie by the way.
-
-
07-12-2007, 03:22 PM #8
I personally didn't appreciate the movie. I'm not even sure David Yates even READ the book before he made the movie.
I can't believe Bellatrix said "Avada Kedavra" to Sirius. This is WRONG. Incredibly wrong. I went and reread that part in the book last night to make sure it wasn't wrong. A "jet of light" is what shoots out of her wand at him, and he falls gracefully back. If it would have been an Avada Kedavra he would have gone flying back or falling over terribly (from what we've seen happen to the only other people we've seen Avada Kedavra'd [Cedric and Lily]) If there is any chance of Sirius coming back from behind the veil in book 7 then the movie ruined it. No one can come back from an Avada Kedavra. If the movie later tries to mess this up too, I'll be ticked. Good luck Warner Bros explaining how Sirius appears from the dead, because the veil does not necessarily mean death. There is still hope for him.
Also, check out this link from MTV. Outlines everything LEFT OUT of the movie. http://www.mtv.com/movies/news/artic...10/story.jhtml
-
07-12-2007, 03:38 PM #9 Originally Posted by rchurchward
Do put into proportion the book length and movie length. They couldnt make it to long but yeah they did leave some stuff out though it was still a good movie.
-
07-13-2007, 12:58 AM #10
Okay gentlemen, allow me to wax elloquently about all that is Harry Potter. Here are my predictions for the book 7. Feel free to counter, but remember, these are all speculations.
#1 - Dumbledore is NOT a dark wizard and IS dead. He was hit with an avada kedavra. There is no way to come back from this. However, if you recall, something white came from his tomb during his funeral. What was this you ask? Possibly a phoenix. Now, Dumbledore is a phoenix. But he is DEAD. No way to come back from an avada kedavra, which he commanded Snape to do at the end of the book, if you recall. They had some sort of agreement. If you guys remember "Severus, please..." and he's gone. He will either be back to help Harry as a phoenix or through his portrait. Secondly, he is not a dark wizard. When Crouch says "I'll show you mine if you show me yours," he is referring to the area on his arm where every Death Eater has the dark mark tattooed. Harry was cut in the exact same place on his arm by Pettigrew. He was marked in the same place the death eaters are marked.
#2 - Harry is the missing horcrux. There are many reasons to think this. First of all, LV used Harry to store a piece of his soul when he sent out the horcruxes. Apparently, no one can find the 6th horcrux, but the proof (the lightning scar) is right in front of them. Plus, when Dumbledore said that LV came to kill Harry, he "chose his equal", correct? How can you be equal unless you have at least half of the other's soul? To split your soul, you need to commit murder; avada kedavra. When voldemort set out to kill Harry's parents, it was so he could have his soul split, which would then, unbeknownst to him, enter Harry. and Voldemort, since he had already split his soul 6 times before turned into a shell of his former self. Therefore, the reason why voldemort was unable to kill Harry is because that's the remaining part of his soul, but he doesn't yet realize it. Because remember, any of the other times he tried to kill Harry the powers seem to bounce back and hurt him when he tries. And when he realizes this, he will assume Harry will want to things that he wants, fame, wealth, power, all his abilities, to be like him, the greatest wizard, greater than Dumbledore. And offering Harry either death or immortality, Harry will figure out what is going on and choose the surprise of voldemorts death. And since Harry knows that the only true way voldemort will be rid is if he dies...it leads me to my last prediction...
#3 - Harry will die. Harry knows that the only way that Voldemort will die is if the rest of the soul that is within Harry is gone too. Therefore, Harry, realizing the burden that has been put on himself, will choose death to defeat LV. Remember, there is no way that LV can die unless all horcruxes are gone. If we assume Harry is a horcrux, he must die before LV. Therefore, Harry will choose death to save the ones he loves, thus making LV mortal and susceptible for attack. In saving those he loves, Harry will die to rejoin his parents. Sound familiar? Sounds a bit like Jesus to me. Nice JKR.
Okay I lied, that's not my last prediction. Last prediction...
#4 - Snape is a good guy. Snape, in book 7, will come to Harry's rescue, but will have to pay the ultimate price, possibly taking an Avada Kedavra in place of Harry. Therefore, Snape will die in book 7.
Thank you ladies and gentlemen, and goodnight.
-
