Trade Advice --help!!!!!

[7772Justin3777]

Quick question- Who gets the better end?

person 1 gets- 04-05 sp authentic quad auto Kidd/Stockton/ Magic/ Marbury 1/15 (slightly dinged edges and corners)

person 2 gets: 05-06 Trilogy Lebron James autofocus bv 350$

[abcdefg]

i would take the deal if i was person 1 any day for a few reasons:
1) it has stockton and magic; the 2 best PG's of all time so the card would still hold value because they're reitred HOF players and their cards probably wouldn't go down in value
2) it's #'d/15
3) the lebron only sells at $175; asnd the quad would probably bring a lot more
4) it has kidd and stockton who are 2 of the better PG's now

[Price6810]

person 2 cause as good as the card is, its damaged and that messes up the value alot

[wmcjhi]

I'd say Person 1, as well. It's a much more limited production run, 2 HOFers, retired as mentioned, and 2 most likely will be HOFers, all autos. As long as the damage is very minimal, it's the better deal. Lebron is hot now, but that's NOW. He could be the next MJ in value, but I dunno, he could also get hurt.

[cubsfan24]

IMO an autograph is an autograph. If it is for your personal collection it shouldn't really matter if it isn't mint on the border. (a crease along the card could be a different story)

also IMO all Lebron autos after 2003-04 will slowly drop in value as years go by due to the fact that Upper Deck will keep placing his Autograph in every product they produce.

Another way to look at it could be how difficult would it be to replace each card? The Lebron Auto would most likely pop up on Ebay fairly regularly because it is Lebron. Who knows the next time you could see this quad auto since there is only 15 made.

I would say that person 1 gets the better end of the deal

[asujbl]

totally depends on the amount of damage...and we can't tell without a scan.

[MrMojo]

person 1 hands down

[Price6810]

i totally change my mind. hes right lebron is replaceable and good luck finding a quad auto with those high class players

[MDIZZ]

the quad no matter what has 3 hall of famers and a not-horrible player in marbury.