QB Advise

[uptonfan1]

I have questions on these three guys, want your thoughts..

Charlie Whitehurst: Will he ever start in the nfl, or beat out Philip Rivers?

Matt Leinart: Will he evr leave up to the hype he had out of USC? Have a productive nfl carrer?

Jay Cutler: how will he turn out?

Thanks for input...

[htwheelz01]

Whitehurst I don't think will ever beat out Rivers. He might get a chance somewhere else but I just don't think there unless Rivers goes down. As far as Leinart goes He might end up being productive but I don't think he will live up to the hype.

[eaglefan52081]

whitehurst- just a back-up QB in the NFL, nothing more

Leinart- not going to live up to the hype, wont take the cards anywhere.

in my opinion of course.

[uptonfan1]

What about Jay Cutler?

[Chiefs2007]

well jay cutler isnt anything special.....

[elgato]

Leinart is out for the season with a broke collar bone.

[D.J.Williams55]

Charlie Whitehurst: as of right now whitehurst is still learn the ropes. as for him beating out rivers, that might take a while. but there is always a chance.

Matt Leinart: lerinart has everything around him to be successful. my only question about him is his arm strengh good enough to get his talented receivers a chance down field?

Jay Cutler: as for cutler the future is bright. his only started 10 games in two season. his arm strengh is equal to that of brett favre. he can be a great QB when he retires from the NFL. the only problem with him is that he came from vanderbilt. at vanderbilt he was to make plays any way he could. and that sometimes gets him into trouble. but this will improve in time.

[buffaloesbest]

I think when Whitehurst gets a chance, he'll shock quite a few people but he won't get a chance behind Rivers.

Leinart- I honestly think he's a good QB but isn't getting a chance to air it out. He defintely has the receivers to let it fly. With some good play calling he'll rise above.

Cutler-Has the perfect offensive scheme going. He has an amazing offensive line for the running game and good pass protection. There's no reason for this guy not to take off. I think he's the best of the three. I think Cutler and Marshall will be a tandem to reckon with...

[bearfield]

Charlie Whitehurst: i think a lot depends on how smart the coach and management is. note, see what belichik does in the off season, every year. everybody sees it, but is anybody smart enough to copy him? not so far. would roethlisberger have been able to do what he did his rookie year without cower and the rest of the team? it takes more than just a quarterback.

Matt Leinart: see above.

Jay Cutler: his coach is pretty smart, depends how smart, and how much serious studying cutler does while healing.

i don't really know, i'm from buffalo, and the management and coaches here have the brains of one of the smilies to the right or under this post.
doesn't really matter, pick one.

OOPS, WHERE DID THEY GO?