When is it expecting too much?

[lghoops92]

I recently made a trade with somebody involving a few of my cards and $5 for a few of his cards.

He complained that one of my cards came damaged, so I said we should send each other the cards back, since it was unfair that he got the short end of the deal. I told him I'd even let him keep the $5 since he was spending money on shipping and it was my fault that a refund was necessary.

He refused and started making other offers that I didn't want to do.

I thought my deal was more than fair. Should I just leave it as a final offer and risk losing trade business with this person forever?

[hepcat]

I think what you offered was more than fair....$5 covers his shipping back and leaves him with a buck or two, and everybody is back to where they were pre-trade (minus his initial s/h and your dual s/h and $5)....seems right

[john1170]

Your offer was more than fair. Tell him to take it or leave it and move on. Just don't make any more deals with him.

[themanishere]

You are totally in the wrong on this one.

You should have offered him a few MJ autos, as well as $1000 cash for his trouble.

[DaClyde]

Is Michael Jackson still signing autos?

[lghoops92]

Yeah he will likely be on my ignore list now

Thanks for your opinions