Who do I take? Aaron Rodgers or Tavaris Jackson?

[chadjacksonfan]

Please I need a little help!

[11chaos]

I moved the thread to where I thought you would get the most bang for the buck so to speak.

Tavaris Jackson has been nursing a hurt leg I believe it was during the latter portion of the preseason. However he can throw and when healthy run. He has a pretty good running back (Until he does it back to back I will just call him pretty good) but lacks someone to throw to.

Aaron Rodgers really an unproven entity. He has someone to throw to Greg Jennings but who after that? All of the running backs got hurt last year if I remember correctly, however they did find one diamond in the rough from all that.

If they are both of your Fantasy Football QB's then I would go with who ever is going up against the weaker of the two Defenses. Hope this helps.

[chadjacksonfan]

This is a Salary cap team so I need to choose to buy one or the other. In the opening week they are playing each other..

Other options are
Campbell leinart croyal and T edwards

[chadjacksonfan]

I moved the thread to where I thought you would get the most bang for the buck so to speak.

Tavaris Jackson has been nursing a hurt leg I believe it was during the latter portion of the preseason. However he can throw and when healthy run. He has a pretty good running back (Until he does it back to back I will just call him pretty good) but lacks someone to throw to.

Aaron Rodgers really an unproven entity. He has someone to throw to Greg Jennings but who after that? All of the running backs got hurt last year if I remember correctly, however they did find one diamond in the rough from all that.

If they are both of your Fantasy Football QB's then I would go with who ever is going up against the weaker of the two Defenses. Hope this helps.

Thanks man! Who would you choose?

[hector234]

Tarvaris Jackson, i know im a big fan/collector of T-JACK, but this year he has a nice deep threat that can catch the ball. If Rice is healthy, he will be a nice target as well. And T-JACK got hurt in the 2nd game, but it's nothing serious. Childress didn't want him from further injuring himself. He looked really really good in preseason.

[11chaos]

Out of all those options
Matt Leinart - A BIG BUST
Jason Campbell - Not ready for primetime, imo
Brodie Croyle - As much as I want this kid to succeed I don't see it
Trent Edwards - He has a big receiver to throw to. Go with this one if possible

1. Edwards
2. Jackson
3. Rodgers
4. Campbell
5. Croyle
31. Leinart

[hector234]

Out of all those options
Matt Leinart - A BIG BUST
Jason Campbell - Not ready for primetime, imo
Brodie Croyle - As much as I want this kid to succeed I don't see it
Trent Edwards - He has a big receiver to throw to. Go with this one if possible

1. Edwards
2. Jackson
3. Rodgers
4. Campbell
5. Croyle
31. Leinart

Edwards I don't see him being a great QB.

[cometmike]

I moved the thread to where I thought you would get the most bang for the buck so to speak.

Tavaris Jackson has been nursing a hurt leg I believe it was during the latter portion of the preseason. However he can throw and when healthy run. He has a pretty good running back (Until he does it back to back I will just call him pretty good) but lacks someone to throw to.

Aaron Rodgers really an unproven entity. He has someone to throw to Greg Jennings but who after that? All of the running backs got hurt last year if I remember correctly, however they did find one diamond in the rough from all that.

If they are both of your Fantasy Football QB's then I would go with who ever is going up against the weaker of the two Defenses. Hope this helps.

What are you talking about?? He has Greg Jennings, Donald Driver, James Jones and also Donald Lee and Ruvell Martin, Plus a few other young ones.

And What RB's got hurt??

[hector234]

What are you talking about?? He has Greg Jennings, Donald Driver, James Jones and also Donald Lee and Ruvell Martin, Plus a few other young ones.

And What RB's got hurt??

Yeah, those guys are good with YAC. But their big plays came on deep passes, which Rodgers has trouble connecting on.

[chadjacksonfan]

hmm... tie breaker.... according to SI rodgers has the best WR staff...

I think for now ill go with Jackson

Second pick rodgers

Then Edwards... Just because I dont like the chance that he will play poorly and have JP losman take the reigns...

Thanks for all the expert advice!