Need some help! LMK if i should do this

[joe31]

Hey i normally trade by bv but this deal that got offered to me idk about
here it is
I get
Marshawn Lynch rc auto with a piece of blu jsy, piece of white jsy, piece of ball /100 bv 120 with sv 50

He gets
Adrian Peterson Bowman Chrome Ref rc bv 80 sv 38

Brian Westbrook Rc auto bv 40 sv 45

plmk

[palantri]

i wouldnt, peterson and westbrook combine to have a much better upside than lynch
ed

[joe31]

ok thanks. anyone else have their opinion?

[gladdyontherise]

i wouldnt, not because of sv/bv, but westbrooks cards are to undervalued to determine a rc auto of his that low, westbrook is a top 3-5 RB right now and gets no credit like the others, i'd keep that card and hold onto it for a little longer

[joe31]

thanks. sounds good

[joe31]

yeah i was sorta suprised b/c the westbrook was selling for more then it books

[palantri]

yeah i was sorta suprised b/c the westbrook was selling for more then it books

further proof that beckett is not a reliable pricing source...but dont get me started on that...lol

Ed

[joe31]

Jw what bv would u put on it

[palantri]

im the wrong guy to ask, because i generally dont care about bv or sv. if i see a card i want at a price i think is fair, i will buy it. similarly, if someone has a card i like, and they like something of mine i dont mind trading for it, i will make the trade. bv and sv are ways for people who are only in the hobby for a profit to turn one...

[joe31]

yeah thats sort of how i feel. i was thinking the same thing you were thats why i posted this, to see what other people would say. he may add in a marion barber rc auto now. now what would u think?