The Most Over Rated.

[kylekyle]

i dont think manning is overrated. what so ever

[chekers]

Football: Payton Manning.
Baseball: Jeter
Basketball:Gilbert Arenas

[MCXC1987]

Manning still makes dumb decisions. He has gotten better. Made a disgustingly lucky play that david tyree couldn't make again...like the steeler game...he mouthed the goaline play and the steelers picked up on it....the giants come out of a time out...and Eli gets flagged for a delay of game....just dumb things, people say he is better then peyton, but i wouldn't put him on the same level.

[kylekyle]

hey is defintely not better than peyton. and ya he defintly does make some bad desiosion . i no what ur sayain

[MCXC1987]

hey is defintely not better than peyton. and ya he defintly does make some bad desiosion . i no what ur sayain

HAHA i'm not arguing he is overated...its just a little early to compare him to peyton...but i'm an eagle fan to lol

[kylekyle]

ya peyton is better but eli won the super bowl earlier, but it doesnt amtter they both won it.

[SK74]

Baseball: David Ortiz
Football: Chad Johnson
Basketball: Not too many overrated in basketball... I'd say maybe Vince Carter since he's been with the Nets.

And just my opinion on this; but I think Eli Manning is UNDERRATED, so many people say he's overrated, I don't get how he possibly is. No one says he's amazing (anymore... after the Super Bowl there was the comparisons to Peyton for a bit), but people will still call him overrated. It just makes no sense that 95% of NFL fans say he's overrated, think about that and ask yourself who calls him great... basically no one.

Other weird ones I've seen are KG (how?), Bynum (most casual fans couldn't tell you what team he plays for), Braylon (imo the best WR in the league, he can make something out of nothing, just drops too many), and Zimmerman... how can a guy who doesn't get attention be overrated?

Well then clearly he is not the best in the league, IMO he's maybe top 5 at best on a good night. I'll take Randy Moss over Edwards any day of the week.

Baseball: I have no idea, I don't watch baseball
Basketball: Gilbert Arenas
Hockey: Evgeni Malkin - but there is a few players who qualify
Football: Peyton Manning

[CrawfordFan13]

What I meant to say is that Edwards has the potential to be the best, if he can get those drops down, I'll take him over anyone.

[macballerbubba]

baseball-ortiz/thome
football-reggie bush
basketball-ben gordon

[SK74]

What I meant to say is that Edwards has the potential to be the best, if he can get those drops down, I'll take him over anyone.

Yeah, he has great potential for sure, the best ? I don't know, maybe in a few years.