Which QB to start in Week 12?

[BoogieDownBerlin]

any opinions

trent edwards @ kansas city

david garrard @ minnesota

kerry collins @ new york (jets)




edwards is struggling, garrard is facing a good defense, is collins the best pick ?

[OnePimpTiger]

Edwards is struggling, but I might still play him...if anything can help you out of a funk, it's the KC D. But Collins should be a decent play...I'd pass on Garrard.

[htwheelz01]

I would half to go with Edwards myself most likely out of that. But Collins could throw 3 TD's again though so who knows.

[BoogieDownBerlin]

ok garrard was my last pick so hes gone

edwards or kollins

i know kc`s defense sucks, but dont know what to expect from edwards right now.

kollins might be the best pick against the jets

[lukehoyt19]

I would go with collins. The jets have had alot of shoot outs this year. Edwards stuggled against Cleveland who is one of the worst defenses this year.

[middit]

How about between these 3:

Roethlisberger vs. Cincy tonight

Cambell @ Seattle

Sage Rosenfels @ Cleveland

[tbog18]

I would go Collins. Jets stop the run pretty good and Collins has shown he's not afraid to throw.

[tennisdevils]

id go david garrard @ minnesota
even though im a vikes fan, our past defense is HORRIBLE!

[OnePimpTiger]

I would go with collins. The jets have had alot of shoot outs this year. Edwards stuggled against Cleveland who is one of the worst defenses this year.

Actually the Browns passing defense is the best out of the three. The Browns pass D is ranked 19, Chiefs are 27 and Jets are 28. They give up fewer passing yards and have more INTs than either of the other two.

[dallascisco]

I'd expect the bills to keep it on the ground. I'd go with collins.