What so I do with this damaged card?

[Rayzorsports]

Upper deck emailed me and said they have replacements for it but they can't guarantee it will have a nice patch like mine. I reall wanted to sell this card but I think the damage brings it down some and If I sent it back and got a 1 or 2 color instead of something like this I would be real upset. What should I do? Send it back? Or does someone on here collect him I could sell this too?





Damage on left side of the card.

[TeamChevelle]

I would risk the replacement, in my view the damaged card is worth nothing. Request the best patch they have. My 2 cents.

[cprince80]

Thats to bad to see that on such a nice card. Personally I would send it back and take my chances with UD.

[geschrocks33]

Take your chances with a replacement.

[Rayzorsports]

This is a tough call because of the patch. I don't see what they can't send me a new one and let me keep this. What are they gonna do with it? Part of the bolt and everything too!!

[Samuwry7]

Another option is to request that your replacement have a similar quality patch, regardless of player. You might actually sneak into a more sellable player that way. Give them a list of players you'd take.

[zPens87z]

I would say send it back, I would rather have a 100% card and a 2 color patch than a 75% card with a 4 color patch.

Just my thoughts...

[Rayzorsports]

Sounds like I am sending it back. Really appreciate your opinions on this!!!

[Samuwry7]

By the way, they judge replacements based on book value. Might be useful, so you know you wont get a Chris Drury or some bs back.*

* I was told this by the GM of the UD store

[Rayzorsports]

Any idea of a BV on this?