Did I win in this trade?

[soxfan34]

I traded away a Felix Hernandez Quad Jersey/Auto /85 of Exquisite

for these...
Jake Peavy SPx Young Stars Auto/Jsy 652/999
J.J. Putz Topps Triple Threads Triple Patch 8/9 Nice!
Brian Roberts Clear-Cut Elements Auto/Jsy 26/350
Clint Barmes Topps Co-Signers Solo Sigs Autograph
Ronny Paulino Topps Autograph
Mike Lowell Autograph


Then, I traded the JJ Putz for these 3...
2008 UD Premier Markakis/Hermida/Hamilton triple auto /25
2007 UD Premier Barfield/Uggla dual auto /25
2007 SPX Jim Thome Dual GU /50

So you could say, I traded the Felix for all of these..
Jake Peavy SPx Young Stars Auto/Jsy 652/999
2008 UD Premier Markakis/Hermida/Hamilton triple auto /25
2007 UD Premier Barfield/Uggla dual auto /25
2007 SPX Jim Thome Dual GU /50
Brian Roberts Clear-Cut Elements Auto/Jsy 26/350
Clint Barmes Topps Co-Signers Solo Sigs Autograph
Ronny Paulino Topps Autograph
Mike Lowell Autograph

So that was a good deal right? Someone told me it was in the other persons favor, when I checked BVs, the Felix booked 40 while the Peavy alone booked 35....

[chipperhank44]

I think you came out ahead, however I do think you gave up quality for quantity. BV says you killed it, SV says you came out ahead as well, but not by nearly much

[CasEjonz]

If you are happy with what you got, then you did well. Everyone values things differently. I like what you got for the Putz card. A King Felix is hard to give up IMO.

[ildd]

2008 UD Premier Markakis/Hermida/Hamilton triple auto /25
i think thats worth the hernandez and more :)

[Javon21Ringer]

This term, "Did I win in this trade"...Is there ever really a winner or loser in a trade...As both parties hold value in different ways for each card received and/or traded...If a trade is agreed upon then both parties are each winners in there own minds...Congrats on your pick-ups!!

[williams51]

Yep I agree with drew5stanton5 both parties got what they wanted congrats on the new additons to your collection

[Jeter+Arod Fan]

You did fantastic!