Please help!!! What is the best trade for me???

[#1BILLSfan]

There are 3 scenarios. Which one is the best for me?


SCENARIO 1:

I GET:
Doug Harvey GU/stick /5
http://s249.photobucket.com/albums/gg210/TMichalak/HOFer%20Traders/?action=view&current=Harvey04-05ITGUltimateStickJerseyGo.jpg

He gets:
crosby Cup Chirography auto /50


SCENARIO 2:

I get:
Bower/Sawchuk/Cujo triple stick (not numbered)
http://cujo31collector.shutterfly.com/4158

He gets:
Crosby Cup Chirography auto /50
Kovalchuk Stick Signings auto /25
Bobby Hull Cup Chirography auto /50


SCENARIO 3:

I get:
Doug Harvey stick /9
Evgeni Malkin SOTT auto
https://www.sportscardforum.com/showthread.php?t=803170 (only Harvey found here)

He gets:
Crosby Cup Chirography auto

[#1BILLSfan]

no one?

[Raptor]

i gues you are on your own for this one

[JoeyJoeJo]

I personally would keep the crosby, but if you have a few crosby autos then i would def. take the goalie card, but i'm not much of a harvey collector either.

[#1BILLSfan]

k thanks anyone else?

[HammerHawks]

Yeah, I wouldn't do any of them.

[jagrnyr68]

personally, i wouldnt do the 2nd one, i would go with 3 if u really want to do one, but i'll go with the masses and say pass on all of them.

[Walter Sobchak]

I dont know alot about the cards you'd be getting in return but I too would say stay away from this deal

[Mack26]

I am going to go against what everyoen else is saying. Do you collect the Maple leafs, cause that card is sweet. The Harveys are nice as well. You can replace the Crosby auto with another copy whenever you want to cause they are always around.

I think trade #2 has the nicest card but might be a bit high going back their way. I can not believe I am actually saying I like a Maple Leaf card cause I hate the Maple Leaf. Maybe I am turning over a new leaf.

[#1BILLSfan]

Thanks guys its just so hard because theres nothing to compare any of them with any sales.