Possible High End Deal- Is it Fair? SCANS

[BravesFan4Life]

Yes unproven. One year does not make a career. All three could be out of the league in two years or they could be All Stars. Proven is Chris Paul, Deron Williams...they have had a few years to show they are going to be around to stay. I do not understand why people think a great rookie year means something. A great first 5 years means something but not always look at Grant Hill, look at Penny Hardaway. You can start out great and something can always happen.(I am talking about their careers not sell values because lets face it Hill and Penny are going to have followings long after both have retired and long after one of those three supposed studs flames out)

Westbrook, Gordon, Mayo- UNPROVEN? Theyre all studs. And Bayless isnt bad either. I think the triple will defenitely hold its value in the future.


BTW- thanks for all the opinions guys.

[beishuizen91]

If we dont get any info here, we should just post it up on hobby kings. Probaly more knowlege on highend cards over there...no offense to the members here lol. Just seems like this is a more kid/teen site than hobbykings.

Well card trading really is a Kid/Teen thing lol.

[nezarnino]

I agree with everything you said except the last line. So thats basically telling everyone, that its OK to get a bad deal if the card you get makes you happy. Bottom line is one day everyone would like to see there favorite card be worth lots of money or that their collection would someday be worth a lot, the majority of collectors on this site change who they collect often. But I dont think anyone is going to trade away highend for a card that makes them happy and books for less then half what they traded. Almost every trade I have made on this site the other person usually trys to get as much as they can in the deal. I have even had a trader ask for more even after the trade was confirmed. lol

Waxbuster off the topic, I may be one of the few people on here but I would trade away a high end card for a card thatmade me happy. To be specific any Brad Banks #1/1 I need for a master set you better believe I would overpay and overtrade for that bad boy. He never even played in the NFL and I know there is no value 6 years after the draft but I would go to town tradewise to get those bad boys. Just wanted to share my two cents..love this thread

[CandyMan23]

I would hands down take the b side, but then again it's up to you. Here are a few things I noticed about the trade, 1st of all the right corner of the stuckey auto seems like it's chipping or damaged (?) anyone else see that? secondly why the **** is there such a big gap between the side a and b bvs? there is a $80 difference, just by that fact alone this trade is a ripoff. Why not even it out a little bit then maybe the trade wouldn't suck so bad.

[ccblec]

I'd take Side B.

-Brandon

[montej1695]

IMO the simple fact that you had to post a thread about a possible trade means that someone wasnt happy with it and you probably shouldn't make the trade.

Hey who cares what cards, what bv's, GU/AU... does it really matter when two parties TRADE they're both happy or else they wouldnt AGREE on it.

GL.

[mufinman009]

Okay guys, obviously I decided against this trade. Sorry for all the ranting and trouble caused by this thread, but also thanks for all the time and opinions.

[montej1695]

Okay guys, obviously I decided against this trade. Sorry for all the ranting and trouble caused by this thread, but also thanks for all the time and opinions.

You got 9 pages of replies... thats pretty impressive.

[mufinman009]

Haha yeah I know. I was defenitely not expecting anywhere near that. Also, please CMB for the Dwight and Mayo Autos, pm me if you like anything, thanks!

[Ray33]

tO BOTH TRADERS INVOLVED: WHO CARES WHAT OTHERS THINK. AS LONG AS YOUR BOTH HAPPY WITH THE TRADE THAT IS WHAT MATTERS.