Possible High End Deal- Is it Fair? SCANS

[waxbuster]

I agree. Even if the Dirk sold for 165 which it doesnt, It would still be a bad deal for side B. Side B has enormous potential espeacially since there will be no big names in this years draft.

[gladdyontherise]

Oh. and for the record, my sole purpous isnt to collect someone that sells well, and my goal isnt to own cards that sell well, i collect because i enjoy the hobby, i collect someone whos cards are cheap, but is still a star in the league, honestly i cant believe i'm the one your bashing, considering i've done nothing to you, oh well, i honestly couldnt care anymore

[waxbuster]

Sometimes its just best to leave the hobby for a min. Or take a risk of embarasssing yourself and your SV's

[jiggidy]

I would take Side B. You can pickup that Stuckey auto on eBay for around $30. Although the only player I think that is going to be better than Stuckey out of the Autos you are giving up is Mayo. The Dirk is nice but I dont think Side A is getting enough for what they are giving up.

[Gtbballer20]

Dont trade that stuff man!!!! Rip off for you

[RenegadeLonghorn]

Lets focus on the topic at hand instead of people's ages, shall we?


I vote side B, for the record.

[NickRadz23]

Side B by a landslide over here as well. Who likes Dirk anyways? lol jk all you Dirk fans!! dont wanna start more trouble on this thread :)

[51CardDeck]

mufinman009: If you have any doubt about the trade, just don't do it.

notoriousek: These posts are only opinions, so don't take anything personally.
Do you have an auction# or link to the auction where it sold for $165?

My Opinion:
As for the Dirk 1/1, only a Dirk collector would be willing to pay a premium.
It's hard to determine the value of a 1/1, and 1 EBay auction does not determine it's sale value. As for the other cards involved in the trade, there have been several auctions, so you can get a basic idea of what people are looking to pay (on EBay).

This Dirk 1/1 sold for $265...that's just what someone was willing to pay.
Unless you're a Dirk collector, I don't think anyone in their right mind would pay this kind of price, but then again, you never know.
DIRK SPX 1/1

For me, none of these cards would go into my PC, so they would just be trade bait cards. If I had a choice, I'd take Side B.

Side A: The Stuckey has room to grow. Would probably EBay the Dirk, as it would be harder to seek out a Dirk collector to trade with.

Side B: All three auto's have room to grow, and the triple is definitely great trade bait. (plenty of multi auto collectors out there)

[theael]

B all day

[#50 Tyler Hansbrough]

I till say side b is the better by a landslide. regardless of the age bashin and the insults